Skip to main content

The Globe and Mail

Defence Minister vetoes Mulcair's visit to military post in Manitoba flood zone

An aerial view of the flooding in the Bird’s Point area of Round Lake in Saskatchewan on Sunday.


Prime Minister Stephen Harper has taken a chopper tour of flood-stricken southern Manitoba but apparently his government doesn't see any need for NDP Leader Thomas Mulcair to see the disaster zone for himself.

Mulcair is to visit Winnipeg today, just as floodwaters are expected to crest in the southwestern part of the province.

With the help of Premier Greg Selinger's office, Mulcair had arranged to get a briefing and a tour of a military command post that's co-ordinating the work of 500 soldiers who've been helping fill sandbags and shore up dikes along the swollen Assiniboine River.

Story continues below advertisement

Brigadier-General Christian Juneau, commander of the third Canadian Division, had agreed to the tour, according to Mulcair's office. All that was needed was a green light from Defence Minister Rob Nicholson.

Late Tuesday, Mulcair was informed that Nicholson had vetoed the visit.

"It's disheartening to see the Conservatives play politics during a crisis," said Mulcair spokesman George Smith.

"This was a simple briefing that had been arranged with the military. There was no reason for the minister to go out of his way and intervene."

A spokeswoman for Nicholson said the government has nixed all tours for the time being.

"The next 48 hours are key to dealing with the Manitoba flood as it is expected to push through Portage La Prairie," Johanna Quinney said in an email.

"As a result, no tours will be approved at this time so our men and women on the ground can focus all their efforts (on) keeping Manitobans and their properties safe during this crucial time."

Story continues below advertisement

There were no similar qualms about disrupting crucial efforts to prepare for the crest on Sunday, when the prime minister took a 20-minute helicopter tour of the flood zone, accompanied by Selinger and local MPs.

"Obviously, we are here to express our solidarity with people, as I know everybody is very concerned about the situation," Harper said after a briefing with emergency personnel at Brandon City Hall.

Selinger's NDP government has welcomed politicians of all partisan stripes who want to see the extent of the crisis for themselves. But it refused to comment on Nicholson's decision to nix Mulcair's visit to the military command post.

"While we think it's important for politicians from across the country to see first hand the devastation that can be caused by a natural disaster like the Manitoba flood, ultimately those decisions are made by the federal government and the military," a Manitoba government spokesperson said.

In a media briefing today, Selinger echoed that sentiment, saying the province is currently focused on helping its residents deal with the crisis.

Selinger declared a state of emergency last Friday and asked for military assistance to help communities at risk of being submerged to prepare for the floodwater crest.

Story continues below advertisement

This summer's flood, triggered by torrential rain and water pouring in from Saskatchewan, could break records set during one of Manitoba's worst floods in 2011.

Report an error
As of December 20, 2017, we have temporarily removed commenting from our articles. We hope to have this resolved by the end of January 2018. Thank you for your patience. If you are looking to give feedback on our new site, please send it along to If you want to write a letter to the editor, please forward to