Skip to main content

The Globe and Mail

Newfoundland Tories restart leadership race after debacle

The Newfoundland flag blows in the wind in Ferryland, NL, August 8, 2013. The next Progressive Conservative leader in Newfoundland and Labrador will take the helm of a government that has dropped in popularity and must face voters within a year of becoming premier.

Jonathan Hayward/The Canadian Press

It's Take Two for Newfoundland and Labrador's governing Tories as they launch a fresh leadership race after the debacle that was their first attempt.

Progressive Conservatives and their critics alike have compared the first attempt to an embarrassment at best, a political gong show at worst.

"Some would say you couldn't write the sequence of events like that if you were to try," Paul Davis said last week as he gave up his post as health minister to contend.

Story continues below advertisement

Nominations close Monday. But Mr. Davis and another cabinet minister, Steve Kent, have so far stepped up along with John Ottenheimer, a former Tory government minister of health and other portfolios.

Mr. Kent resigned as municipal affairs minister to run. The winner will be chosen Sept. 13 at a delegated convention in St. John's. An election is expected some time in 2015, if not sooner.

It's a far cry from the first leadership contest that attracted not one high-profile Tory. It was triggered when former premier Kathy Dunderdale quit in January after a slide in the polls and her handling of power blackouts raised doubts about her leadership.

Premier Tom Marshall took over on an interim basis but wants to retire.

Progressive Conservatives have held a majority in the legislature since 2003 but trail the Opposition Liberals in recent polls. They've also lost three by-elections, two in former Tory strongholds.

Just three caucus outsiders lined up to take Ms. Dunderdale's place before a string of bizarre incidents left political neophyte Frank Coleman as the only candidate left standing in the race.

The successful businessman from Corner Brook faced a media barrage over his pro-life views and a government contract involving one of his former companies. He shocked even Tory insiders when he suddenly withdrew last month, nixing a planned coronation.

Story continues below advertisement

Mr. Coleman cited an undisclosed family matter for his decision. He became the sole contender after the party ejected one of his two opponents, retired naval officer Wayne Bennett, for Twitter posts that compared his online critics to Muslim terrorists. The other challenger, fishery magnate Bill Barry, dropped out after saying the race was stacked in Mr. Coleman's favour.

Mr. Coleman's exit created a whole new set of circumstances, said Davis, who declined to enter the first race last March and endorsed the businessman.

"I was in a different place personally and my health was in a different place," said the former police officer and spokesman for the Royal Newfoundland Constabulary.

Mr. Davis, who was first elected in a 2010 by-election and previously served as a town councillor and deputy mayor of Conception Bay South near St. John's, is already hailed by some pundits as the one to beat.

Mr. Kent, 36, a former mayor of Mount Pearl outside St. John's and a strident defender of the Tory government's record, has nothing but good things to say about Mr. Davis, a friend for two decades. He helped Mr. Davis win his first municipal campaign in 2001.

"That's one of the reasons I believe this will be a clean, spirited, positive race," Mr. Kent, first elected provincially in 2007, said in an interview.

Story continues below advertisement

Both Mr. Davis and Mr. Kent so far have the support of one cabinet minister each along with several caucus members. Mr. Ottenheimer, 61, declared his candidacy last month and said he also has cabinet and caucus backing.

Stephen Tomblin, a political scientist at Memorial University of Newfoundland, called the first leadership round "a train wreck."

The Tories now have an especially credible candidate in Mr. Davis, he said. Mr. Ottenheimer totes political baggage from his time as health minister in 2005 amidst a scandal over botched breast cancer tests, while Mr. Kent unsuccessfully sought a Liberal nomination for a federal by-election in 2000 after testing the waters with the far-right Canadian Alliance.

Report an error
As of December 20, 2017, we have temporarily removed commenting from our articles. We hope to have this resolved by the end of January 2018. Thank you for your patience. If you are looking to give feedback on our new site, please send it along to If you want to write a letter to the editor, please forward to