Skip to main content

The Globe and Mail

Quebec appeal judge seen as likely pick for top court

Marie-France Bich, 56, of the Quebec Court of Appeal is the likely candidate to be appointed by Prime Minister Harper to the Supreme Court of Canada.


A former university professor who is a respected expert in constitutional, administrative and labour law is emerging as a strong favourite for the next appointment to the Supreme Court of Canada.

Prime Minister Stephen Harper is expected to choose imminently from a list of three candidates that an all-party Parliamentary committee has prepared.

Two more Quebec vacancies will arise in the coming years, when Mr. Justice Morris Fish reaches mandatory retirement in 2013, and when Mr. Justice Louis LeBel retires in 2014. The two people not selected in this round are bound to figure prominently later.

Story continues below advertisement

Madam Justice Marie-France Bich, 56, of the Quebec Court of Appeal is widely seen as the leading contender for the nomination. A full-time law professor at the University of Montreal from 1983 until her 2004 appointment to the Quebec Court of Appeal, Judge Bich also presided over the Quebec bar association's labour and employment law committee from 1997 to 2004. Choosing her would spare Mr. Harper the controversy of not replacing Madam Justice Marie Deschamps with a woman.

In interviews after she retired, Judge Deschamps created an expectation that her replacement will be female by endorsing the current gender composition of the court.

"He's got two more openings coming up next year, so Mr. Harper might be wise to choose a woman right now to settle that issue right away," a prominent Montreal lawyer observed.

Leading candidates include two other Quebec Court of Appeal jurists – Mr. Justice Nicholas Kasirer, 52, and Madam Justice France Thibault. A third judge on the court, Mr. Justice Pierre Dalphond, is seen as highly qualified, but handicapped by past associations with the Liberal Party.

Elevated from Quebec Superior Court to the Court of Appeal in 2002, Judge Dalphond, 54, "has a very strong intellect and sits on most of the important constitutional hearings," said Silvana Conte, a Montreal litigator.

An early favourite for the job, the appeal court's Chief Justice, Nicole Duval Hesler, is now considered less likely to go to the Supreme Court. At 67, she is said to be cool to the idea of moving to Ottawa to take on such a gruelling assignment. Moreover, she has barely settled into her new office after being elevated to the chief justice position less than a year ago.

Mr. Harper has appointed four of the nine judges on the Supreme Court, meaning that he is well on the way to refashioning the very bench that will ultimately rule on the legitimacy of several controversial aspects of his criminal law reform package.

Story continues below advertisement

The Prime Minister's four previous appointees were known quantities: conservative jurists with no track record of writing decisions that expand the law into new areas or restrain the actions of legislators.

Legal observers expect that his next appointments will bear the same hallmark – a factor that could count against candidates such as Judge Kasirer, who is considered a progressive legal thinker.

At other levels of court, Quebec Court of Appeal's Mr. Justice Richard Wagner, 55, is considered a strong contender for the vacancy, as is Federal Court of Appeal Judge Robert Mainville.

While it is rare for Supreme Court appointees to come straight from the bar, the opportunity to pick three judges in quick succession could open the way for Mr. Harper to choose one of three litigators who have appeared often before the Supreme Court – Guy Pratte, Guy DuPont and Pierre Bienvenu.

The mechanics of gleaning feedback from top judges and bar associations has stretched the process close to the beginning of the court's fall hearing session, on Oct.10.

"Work by the selection committee is ongoing," said Julie Di Mambro, press secretary to Justice Minister Rob Nicholson. "An announcement will be made in due course."

Story continues below advertisement

In light of a developing convention that the office of the chief justice rotates between French- and English-Canadian judges, one of the three Quebec appointments stands a good chance of replacing Chief Justice Beverley McLachlin when she retires.

Report an error Licensing Options
About the Author
Justice reporter

Born in Montreal, Aug. 3, 1954. BA (Journalism) Ryerson, 1979. Previously covered environment beat, Queen's Park. Toronto courts bureau from 1981-85. Justice beat from 1985 - present. More


The Globe invites you to share your views. Please stay on topic and be respectful to everyone. For more information on our commenting policies and how our community-based moderation works, please read our Community Guidelines and our Terms and Conditions.

Please note that our commenting partner Civil Comments is closing down. As such we will be implementing a new commenting partner in the coming weeks. As of December 20th, 2017 we will be shutting down commenting on all article pages across our site while we do the maintenance and updates. We understand that commenting is important to our audience and hope to have a technical solution in place January 2018.

Discussion loading… ✨