Go to the Globe and Mail homepage

Jump to main navigationJump to main content

(The Canadian Press)
(The Canadian Press)

With Ottawa's finances looking up, provinces still feel the crunch Add to ...

The very same day that Ottawa releases its fiscal plan, New Brunswick will deliver a budget that Conservative Finance Minister Blaine Higgs has warned will be the start of an aggressive, four-year effort to get spending under control. Mr. Higgs and his colleagues are well aware there is no easy route to firmer fiscal footing, having swept into office on a wave of anger over former Liberal premier Shawn Graham's poorly communicated and ultimately abortive attempt to boost provincial coffers by selling New Brunswick's hydro utility to Quebec.

A week later, Ontario Premier Dalton McGuinty, who faces voters on Oct. 6, will take another crack at keeping the bond markets and his Conservative challenger Tim Hudak at bay, by outlining how he intends to slay the province's massive deficit now that arbitrators have shown they won't play along with his voluntary wage restraint plan. Already, Mr. McGuinty has balked at Mr. Flaherty's call for provinces to get back into the black at the same time the federal government plans to, aiming instead for the 2017-18 fiscal year.

Ontario is viewed as having more time because most of its debt is long term, so it is less sensitive to the short-term ripple effects of Bank of Canada interest rate increases - which could resume on the eve of the fall campaign. But that doesn't change the difficulty of the task ahead.

"The difference between now and, say, 20 years ago when Ontario was also faced with very large budget deficits, is we're unlikely to be skated onside by a manufacturing boom, a quick reversal in the U.S. economy and the tailwind of a relatively weak currency," said Doug Porter, deputy chief economist at BMO Capital Markets in Toronto. "This time will require more restraint."

Former federal finance minister John Manley, who now heads the Canadian Council of Chief Executives, recently urged Ontario Finance Minister Dwight Duncan to wage "war" on debt, arguing, "as events in Europe have made all too clear - investors don't have to buy your bonds," and, "If the market becomes jittery about your ability to repay, the interest burden will soar."

For now, foreign investors - drawn in by Canada's resources, Ottawa's better fiscal position compared with other advanced countries and a strong financial sector - continue to snap up Canadian bonds, including billions in debt issued by the provinces. Even Moody's, which in 2009 cut New Brunswick's rating - the agency's first such cut for a province in a dozen years - is reserving judgment on further downgrades.

"What we're looking for is a clarification of the steps they're going to take in order to achieve their fiscal plans," Jennifer Wong, an analyst with Moody's who specializes in provincial debt, said in an interview, adding the caveat that "the longer [the path back to balance]is, the greater the risk that you may not be able to follow that path."

Indeed, in an outlook released last week, Moody's warned the "magnitude of the task" and the prospect of several elections this year raise the risk that some provincial governments won't have the nerve to take the necessary steps.

And the long-term effect of that could be to drain Ottawa's finances, too. As the population ages and some provinces' labour force shrinks, so too will their tax base.

"We don't know what those transfer arrangements are going to be looking like after 2013," Mr. Dodge said, so "whether this becomes Ottawa's problem depends on what extent you think Ottawa is going to have to come up with the additional funds for health care, or whether that ends up being a purely provincial problem."

Mr. Flaherty has rung alarm bells of late, telling a business audience last month that tackling government debt is a "collective responsibility that must become a reality," while acknowledging that most provinces now have "clear time-frames and plans."

According to Conference Board chief economist Glen Hodgson - a former international debt specialist at the Finance Department - history shows markets don't get nervous about governments' ability to manage and repay their debts until it reaches about 80 per cent of GDP.

Add federal and provincial obligations together, though, and Quebec is already in that warning zone, with Ontario getting closer. As Europe discovered in spectacular fashion, shortfalls can't be punted forever.

"You can probably get to 100 [per cent]or beyond before markets really get worried, which is what happened to Greece last year," Mr. Hodgson said. Nonetheless, "this is the season in which we will expect governments everywhere to ensure that the stimulus is withdrawn, and that they put in place a plan that shows how they're going to get back to balanced budgets."

With reports from Barrie McKenna and John Ibbitson in Ottawa and Karen Howlett in Toronto

Report Typo/Error
Single page

Follow us on Twitter: @curryb, @jeremytorobin


Next story




Most popular videos »

More from The Globe and Mail

Most popular