Skip to main content

The Globe and Mail

Would-be Canadian citizens set to fight oath to Queen

A Royal Canadian Mounted Police officer raises his hand as a group of 60 people take the oath of citizenship during a special Canada Day citizenship ceremony in Vancouver, B.C., on Sunday July 1, 2012.

DARRYL DYCK/The Canadian Press

A small group of landed immigrants with republican views who have refused Canadian citizenship because the ceremony involves swearing an oath to the Queen will be in a Toronto courtroom on Friday, facing off with the federal government in an attempt to have this citizenship requirement declared unconstitutional.

But with a royal baby on the way, and a federal government under Prime Minister Stephen Harper that has dedicated itself to reviving the country's connection to the monarchy – restoring the word Royal to the Royal Canadian Air Force, among other measures – the dissenters may have their work cut out for them.

In court, the federal government is set to argue simply that immigrants who disagree with the idea of a hereditary head of state, and refuse to swear an oath of loyalty, do not deserve the benefits of citizenship.

Story continues below advertisement

"The inability to enjoy the benefits of citizenship – to hold a Canadian passport and to vote – are amongst the costs reasonably borne by individuals whose personal beliefs run contrary to Canada's foundational constitutional structure," a lawyer for the federal Attorney-General says in written arguments submitted in advance of Friday's hearing.

The Toronto lawyer for the people fighting the oath, Peter Rosenthal, said that position was surprising: "The Attorney-General has taken the position that if you don't believe in the monarchy, it's appropriate to deny you the right to vote. That's pretty extraordinary, given the fact that more than half of Canadians don't believe in the monarchy."

Friday's court fight is the latest chapter in more than 20 years of failed legal challenges to the citizenship oath spearheaded by Trinidadian-born Toronto activist and lawyer Charles Roach, who died last year at 79, never having become a Canadian citizen.

Mr. Roach, a long-time friend of Mr. Rosenthal, refused to swear the oath and become a citizen because he believed the Queen was a symbol of imperialism and because of injustices done to his ancestors in the name of the British monarchy.

Among the would-be citizens now represented by Mr. Rosenthal is Michael McAteer, 79, a long-time republican who grew up in Ireland but has lived in Canada since 1964. He has never been able to become a citizen because of his refusal to swear the oath.

Mr. McAteer, a former journalist at the Toronto Star, calls the monarchy an "anachronistic" institution ill-suited to Canada's multicultural society.

"I obey the law. I've probably seen more of Canada than most Canadians. I've shovelled my sidewalk, and you know, paid taxes," he said. "I feel very comfortable here, in Canada. But still, after all that, I still cannot become a Canadian citizen."

Story continues below advertisement

The legal application in court Friday seeks to have the part of the oath that refers to swearing allegiance to "Queen Elizabeth the Second, Queen of Canada, her Heirs and Successors" struck down because it violates the protections for freedom of religion and conscience in the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.

The applicants also argue it violates their freedom of expression, by appearing to bar them from agitating for the abolishing of the monarchy, although they acknowledge this would probably never be enforced against them. They also argue the oath is discriminatory, because citizens born in the country are not required to swear allegiance to the Queen.

One of the applicants, Simone Topey, is a Rastafarian, who, according to a court filing, believes that the Queen is the "Queen of Babylon" and that swearing the oath would "deeply violate her religious belief." Another applicant, Dror Bar-Natan, calls the oath "repulsive" because he says the Queen is a symbol of inequality.

A spokeswoman for the Ministry of Citizenship and Immigration said the government had no plans to change the oath.

"Canadian citizenship is an honour and a privilege," spokeswoman Sonia Lesage said. "The government has been working hard to maintain the integrity of the system and to increase the value of Canadian citizenship."

Report an error Licensing Options
About the Author
Toronto City Hall Reporter

Jeff Gray is The Globe and Mail’s Toronto City Hall reporter. He has worked at The Globe since 1998. From 2010 to 2016, he was the law reporter in Report on Business, covering Bay Street law firms and white-collar crime. He won an honourable mention at the National Magazine Awards for investigative journalism in 2010. More


The Globe invites you to share your views. Please stay on topic and be respectful to everyone. For more information on our commenting policies and how our community-based moderation works, please read our Community Guidelines and our Terms and Conditions.

Please note that our commenting partner Civil Comments is closing down. As such we will be implementing a new commenting partner in the coming weeks. As of December 20th, 2017 we will be shutting down commenting on all article pages across our site while we do the maintenance and updates. We understand that commenting is important to our audience and hope to have a technical solution in place January 2018.

Discussion loading… ✨