Skip to main content

The Globe and Mail

Talks with striking library workers to resume Monday night

Toronto Public Library workers march outside Toronto Reference Library on March 19, 2012 after talks with the city stalled on the weekend. Toronto's 2,300 library employees walked off the job after 5 p.m. Sunday, shuttering 98 branches to bibliophiles across the city.

Fred Lum/The Globe and Mail/Fred Lum/The Globe and Mail

Talks are expected to resume between the Toronto Public Library and its workers Monday night, a little more than 24 hours after the union announced its intention to strike.

"The employer asked if we'd be willing to meet, and we are prepared to listen to proposals," said Cim Nunn, a CUPE spokesman, adding Local 4948 president Maureen O'Reilly was already en route to the hotel where marathon talks took place over the weekend.

Neither management nor the union has shut down its negotiating room at the Westin Prince Hotel on York Mills Road.

Story continues below advertisement

Councillor Paul Ainslie, the library board chairman, said a bargaining session previously set up for Monday night was still on as far as he knew.

"We have talks scheduled for [Monday]evening. Hopefully they'll show up," he said.

Toronto's 2,300 library employees walked off the job after 5 p.m. Sunday, shuttering 98 branches to bibliophiles across the city.

It's the first strike in the amalgamated library's history, and both sides say a failure to agree on job security and benefits for part-timers drove workers to the picket lines.

"The [Toronto Public Library]board is still seeking to gut job security so that more than half of our membership is vulnerable to job loss, making it easier for the city to close branches in the next budget," Ms. O'Reilly told a mid-day rally at Nathan Phillips Square.

On the first day of the first labour disruption of his mayoralty, Rob Ford rushed past reporters with barely a comment while hundreds of Toronto's striking library workers rallied outside city hall.

"We want a settlement, we don't want anyone on strike," Mr. Ford said before slipping back into his office after his weekly weigh-in Monday morning.

Story continues below advertisement

The library strike could be just the beginning of the Ford administration's labour pains.

More than 23,000 inside employees – including those who work at daycares, recreation centres and municipal offices – are scheduled to take a strike vote Tuesday.

Members of CUPE Local 79 will be in a legal strike or lockout position at 12:01 a.m. Saturday.

For both the library and inside workers, job security remains – or what the Ford administration calls 'job for life' – remains a major issue.

In the library's case, the collective agreement that expired Dec. 31, 2011, protected all permanent full and part-time workers from losing their jobs to privatization or new technology.

Ms. O'Reilly, of the library union, said management wants to weaken the contract so fewer than half her members retain that right – something she insisted would open the door to closing libraries.

Story continues below advertisement

Mr. Ainslie has said in the past that the city has no plans to shut branches.

"When I look out at other work places and what they are getting for part-time job security, I think the library was given a very reasonable offer that I was shocked they decided not to accept," Mr. Ainslie said. "I think they walked away from a good deal."

Earlier this year, the Ford administration managed to wring a major concession on job security from CUPE Local 416, which represents more than 6,000 outside workers.

The outside workers inked a deal which limited job protection to workers with 15 years or more of seniority.

Deputy Mayor Doug Holyday said it's no secret the city is using the Local 416 agreement as a template for other unions. Right now all permanent, full-time employees of Local 79 benefit from the job security clause. Part-timers do not, a CUPE spokeswoman said.

"I don't see how they can expect us to give them more than we gave 416," Mr. Holyday said of Local 79. "They want it so that there is no contracting out, which would give job security not just to permanent employees but to all, even temporary and part-time people. No one in the real world does that. Just how far can they take such a matter?"

That depends, in part, on the strength of the strike mandate Local 79's membership receives from its members Tuesday.

While they prepare to vote, some of their Local 4948 counterparts complained about Mr. Ford as they prepared to march outside city hall.

"I'm very disappointed in him," said James Burling, 28, a part-time public service assistant at the Brookbanks branch near Victoria Park Avenue and York Mills Road. "I feel like there's a level of ignorance running through city hall right now that's kind of frightening."

Mr. Burling has worked at the library since he was a teenager. He's a part-timer by choice, and loves his job. He's heartened that the union is fighting for the rights of the part-timers.

"I feel like the part-timers don't really have a lot of say in what happens," he said.

Unlike Mr. Burling, Dolores Sirola wants desperately to land a full-time job at the North York central branch, where she's shelved books for a year.

"It's difficult financially," the 32-year-old said of making ends meet on 10 to 14 hours a week. "I really love working at the library, but because they're trying to cut positions I won't be able to move up or get more hours."

With files from Elizabeth Church

Report an error Editorial code of conduct Licensing Options
As of December 20, 2017, we have temporarily removed commenting from our articles. We hope to have this resolved by the end of January 2018. Thank you for your patience. If you are looking to give feedback on our new site, please send it along to If you want to write a letter to the editor, please forward to