Go to the Globe and Mail homepage

Jump to main navigationJump to main content

AdChoices
TORONTO, SEPT 27, 2016 - BAR VOLO - A waitress serves beer poured from one of the 26 A-Z taps in Bar Volo at 612 College on Tuesday September 27, 2016. The on tap selection serves mostly wild ales, Belgian and farmhouse styles beers while the Cantina is stocked with rare Italian beer bottles from Loverbeer (they are also importers and brought these in especially for the bar) Glenn Lowson photo for The Globe and Mail (For The Globe and Mail)
TORONTO, SEPT 27, 2016 - BAR VOLO - A waitress serves beer poured from one of the 26 A-Z taps in Bar Volo at 612 College on Tuesday September 27, 2016. The on tap selection serves mostly wild ales, Belgian and farmhouse styles beers while the Cantina is stocked with rare Italian beer bottles from Loverbeer (they are also importers and brought these in especially for the bar) Glenn Lowson photo for The Globe and Mail (For The Globe and Mail)

Globe editorial

Globe editorial: Interprovincial free trade at last! (But read the fine print) Add to ...

For decades, Canadian governments have talked and talked about tearing down interprovincial barriers and turning Canada into a genuine free-trade area. They have repeatedly done nothing of the sort. Federal-provincial conferences have come and gone, with little improvement on the old Agreement on Internal Trade of 1995, which was itself only a partial dismantling of the trade walls between provinces.

The new Canadian Free Trade Agreement, agreed to on Friday, might be a big leap forward – eventually. No, it doesn’t tear down all the barriers. But it at least catalogues its own defects.

The CFTA is based on the idea that interprovincial rules should be harmonized and trade should be free – except for exceptional exceptions. Those exceptions, which are legion, are documented in a “negative list.” It reminds Ottawa and the provinces of the work to be done.

The listing of all the exceptions to free trade in a free-trade agreement is one of the reasons why the document is more than 300 pages long. The plan is to whittle down the exemptions over time. Supposedly, too, any new barriers will need to be approved by special negotiations, not the other way around.

It’s awfully Canadian. It’s not exactly a new broom sweeping away all internal trade barriers, harmonizing standards and recognizing professional credentials across provinces. Instead, the CFTA looks more like a process that has established a process to begin the process of processing all of the above. Yeah.

Much of the CFTA reveals daunting, unnecessary barriers – obstacles to trade in large, long-established industries such as energy, forestry, liquor and alcoholic beverages. Is it really so difficult to “harmonize standards” in cutting down trees? Does the CFTA really have to establish a committee to make “recommendations to enhance trade in beer, wine and spirits within Canada.” Why is all of this so hard?

Report Typo/Error

Follow us on Twitter: @GlobeDebate

 

Next story

loading

Trending

loading

Most popular videos »

More from The Globe and Mail

Most popular