Skip to main content

A family, claiming to be from Columbia, is arrested by RCMP officers as they cross the border into Canada from the United States as asylum seekers on April 18, 2018 near Champlain, NY.Paul Chiasson/The Canadian Press

The federal Liberals plan to spend an extra $114.7-million to help pay for temporary housing for asylum seekers – a sum Ontario’s government criticized as being hundreds of millions short of what is needed.

The influx of irregular migrants has increased pressure on provinces to provide shelter and social services. Cities too have felt the crunch with the mayors of Canada’s largest cities on Monday calling for more federal housing money they say is badly needed.

A spokeswoman for Border Security Minister Bill Blair said the extra spending – referenced among $2.5-billion in new spending plans tabled late Monday by the government – is an acknowledgment that irregular border crossers have had a significant impact in places like Toronto and Montreal.

The money is on top of $50-million the Trudeau government offered to Quebec, Ontario and Manitoba last summer to help with temporary housing costs for asylum seekers.

The majority of the money, $100-million, will flow to provinces, with the remaining $14.7-million earmarked for temporary housing provided by the federal government.

No breakdown has yet been offered on exactly how much each province or municipality will receive as part of this planned new spending, nor about how decisions will be made on what eligible costs will be covered.

Word of the coming cash for asylum seekers comes after Toronto unveiled its proposed city budget with a $45-million gap it wants filled by the federal government, to compensate the city for its anticipated costs of sheltering refugee claimants in 2019.

Toronto Mayor John Tory, in Ottawa this week, spoke with Mr. Blair about the need for the money. And Don Peat, a spokesman for Tory, said the mayor was “personally assured” by Blair that more assistance was coming, on top of the $26-million Ottawa has already committed to Toronto.

But Peat could not say if the new money included $45-million for Toronto and referred questions about it to the federal government.

A spokeswoman for Blair would not say how much of the cash was destined for Toronto. In an e-mail, Marie-Emmanuelle Cadieux said the federal government “continues to engage” with municipalities and the provincial governments of Quebec and Ontario to reach “cost-sharing agreements with the provinces, which remain best-placed to manage pressures felt across their cities.”

However, the new spending falls far short of what the Ontario and Quebec governments say they have spent on irregular migrants, $200-million and $300-million respectively.

On Tuesday, Ontario Social Services Minister Lisa MacLeod tweeted Tuesday that the new spending is “a full $400-million less than the request from us (Ontario) and Quebec combined.”

MacLeod was not made available for an interview. Her office said the minister provided a cost breakdown in August and the legislature has asked the provincial auditor general to review Ontario’s asylum seeker costs to ensure transparency.

In July, Immigration Minister Ahmed Hussen called his provincial counterpart’s hard line stance on border crossers “dangerous” and “not Canadian.” MacLeod, whose provincial department oversees immigration, called Hussen’s comments “divisive rhetoric” and walked away from participating in an ad hoc intergovernmental task force on irregular migration.

The Liberals have blamed the frosty relationship with Ontario Premier Doug Ford’s government to explain why some cities didn’t get money to help defray housing costs. Ottawa Mayor Jim Watson said Monday that housing irregular migrants cost his city $5.7-million in 2017, but said federal compensation only flowed to Toronto, which received $11-million last year.

In response, the federal Liberals accused the Ford government of not playing ball in funding negotiations.

“The federal government cannot work directly, efficiently, with the municipalities in Ontario. We work effectively with the province of Quebec, we’ve been doing that for many months and it works, it helps municipalities. In Ontario, the missing player is the government of Ontario,” Social Development Minister Jean-Yves Duclos told reporters Monday.

“However ambitious and willing we are to assist cities like Ottawa, we need the partnership of the government of Ontario, and that complicates our relationships with cities across Ontario.”

The rest of the $2.5-billion in new money in Monday’s spending plans include $323.2-million for demand-driven services to veterans; $313.9-million for international military missions; $163.5-million to write off unrecoverable Canada student loans; $159-million for arctic and offshore patrol ships and $149.7-million to fund the government’s feminist international-assistance agenda.

With files from Jeff Gray

Report an error