Skip to main content

The Globe and Mail

Air Canada seeks $150-million special pension cap


Air Canada wants to cap special payments toward its pension fund deficit at $150-million a year for the next decade, a letter from chief executive Calin Rovinescu to Finance Minister Jim Flaherty shows.

The April 26 letter, received by Reuters on Thursday under access-to-information legislation, formally requested a cap of that amount from 2014 through 2023, as long as the pension fund remained in deficit.

Air Canada has already won approval from its labour unions and its pensioners for a cap, but as recently as Nov. 8, Mr. Rovinescu declined in a conference call with analysts to confirm that the amount of the cap he was seeking was $150-million.

Story continues below advertisement

Mr. Rovinescu said the $2.2-billion increase in Air Canada's pension deficit during 2011 was the result of a reduction in the discount rate used to calculate pension liabilities, to 3.3 per cent from 4.5 per cent.

"This is not sustainable in the current context, assuming no material increase in interest rates," Mr. Rovinescu wrote to Mr. Flaherty.

He said the increase brought the total deficit to $4.4-billion. The airline, Canada's largest, has subsequently revised that down to $4.2-billion.

Air Canada, like other employers with defined-benefit pension plans, has been badly hurt by the decline in the interest rates that are used to calculate solvency gaps.

All but 7 per cent of Canada's federally regulated, private defined-benefit plans were underfunded at the end of 2011, the federal supervisor said on Oct. 5.

In his conference call with analysts on Nov. 8, Mr. Rovinescu said, "We have no assurance of being able to get anything along the lines of what has been asked" for a cap on the special pension payments. "I think that there were some references that were made in the arbitration materials that talked about the numbers along the lines of what you've indicated.

"We're not able to confirm that's been granted, and so we're hopeful of having funding that's satisfactory, but until it's done, it's not done."

Story continues below advertisement

Following approval by the unions and pensioners for the cap, the airline is now awaiting Mr. Flaherty's decision on whether to approve it. Mr. Flaherty's office has so far declined to hint when he will decide.

In 2009, Air Canada won agreement from the government for a moratorium on making any special payments to reduce its pension deficit through 2010, and then a cap on special payments that would rise from $150-million in 2011 to $225-million in 2013.

Justifying his request, Mr. Rovinescu told the finance minister how the airline had "worked diligently to address our pension solvency challenges."

The pension plans have delivered top-quartile performance in the past three years; the company paid $1.8-billion in pension payments over five years; and negotiations with unions were expected to reduce liabilities by $1.2-billion, he said.

"However, despite these significant and hard-fought achievements, the stability and sustainability of our DB (defined-benefit) plans continues to be threatened for reasons completely beyond the company's control," he said.

Report an error
As of December 20, 2017, we have temporarily removed commenting from our articles. We hope to have this resolved by the end of January 2018. Thank you for your patience. If you are looking to give feedback on our new site, please send it along to If you want to write a letter to the editor, please forward to