Skip to main content

The Globe and Mail

Bombardier loses bid for Indonesian airline order

Bombardier’s Q400 aircraft in this undated handout photo. European plane maker ATR has beat out Bombardier Inc. on an important turboprop order from an Indonesian airline.

Handout via Bombardier

European plane maker ATR has beat out Bombardier Inc. on an important turboprop order from an Indonesian airline.

State-owned PT Garuda Indonesia has decided to go with ATR's 72-600 turboprop aircraft over Bombardier's Q400 plane, with a firm order for 25 units and options on 10 more.

The total value of the deal, including options, is about $840-million (U.S.).

Story continues below advertisement

Bombardier Aerospace spokesman Marc Duchesne said in an interview Wednesday that the Montreal-based company pitched Garuda, but that the carrier appears to have decided it didn't require the greater performance, longer range and roomier interior of the Q400.

The Q400 also costs more, he said.

Garuda president and chief executive officer Emirsyah Satar said in a news release that the ATR 72-600 is the best choice for the short-haul flights and operations between the various islands of Indonesia.

Garuda plans to lease the ATR aircraft from Nordic Aviation Capital.

One of ATR's arguments in the marketing of the ATR 72 is that the Q400 burns up to 47 per cent more jet fuel on shorter routes than its own plane.

Bombardier counters that it is misleading to stress the ATR 72's fuel economy because there are many factors to consider, including the Q400's versatility on different types of routes.

Bombardier maintains a good relationship with Garuda, with orders for several CRJ1000 regional jets it put in last year, said Mr. Duchesne.

Story continues below advertisement

Bombardier and another Indonesia airline, Lion Air, confirmed last week they are in talks over a possible deal to buy the jet manufacturer's new narrow-body C Series jet.

The C Series made it first flight last month.

Report an error Editorial code of conduct Licensing Options
As of December 20, 2017, we have temporarily removed commenting from our articles. We hope to have this resolved by the end of January 2018. Thank you for your patience. If you are looking to give feedback on our new site, please send it along to If you want to write a letter to the editor, please forward to