Skip to main content

The Globe and Mail

London trader’s ‘personal greed’ nets him two years for insider dealing

A woman leaves the offices of the Financial Services Authority (FSA) in Canary Wharf, London in a file photo. Former trader Paul Milsom was jailed for two years on Thursday as part of the FSA’s biggest investigation into insider trading.

© Simon Newman/Reuters

Former share trader Paul Milsom was jailed for two years on Thursday for insider dealing, the first sentence to come out of the biggest investigation into the crime by the Financial Services Authority (FSA).

Mr. Milsom, 45, who was a senior equities trader at Legal & General Group PLC, had pleaded guilty. He was ordered to pay £245,000 ($368,000 U.S.), the total profit he made from insider dealing.

He will serve half his sentence before being released on parole.

Story continues below advertisement

Six others have been charged as a result of the FSA's Operation Tabernula, which began in March 2010 with co-ordinated dawn raids in which seven employees of institutions including Deutsche Bank AG and Moore Capital Management were arrested. A total of 10 arrests have been made as part of the investigation.

Passing sentence on Mr. Milsom, judge Jeffrey Pegden said the main impact of insider dealing was a "subversive effect on market confidence."

Mr. Milsom cried in the dock as his lawyer, Simon Ray, described him as a hard-working man who had left school at 16 and worked his way up from a first job as an office junior.

Mr. Milsom had pleaded guilty to one charge that covered 28 instances of passing insider information to Graeme Shelley, then a broker at Novum Securities, between October 2008 and March 2010.

Mr. Shelley has also been arrested and charged as part of Operation Tabernula but has indicated he would plead not guilty.

Mr. Milsom admitted he would tip off Mr. Shelley before executing large trades that had the potential to move a market. Mr. Shelley would then place either spread bets or contracts for difference intended to gain from the market move, and the pair would split any profit.

Contracts for difference are derivatives that allow traders to bet on stocks without having to buy the stocks themselves.

Story continues below advertisement

The 28 deals made by Mr. Shelley based on tips from Mr. Milsom covered 14 stocks including Tui Travel PLC and Invensys PLC. The profit split was roughly 40 per cent to Mr. Milsom and 60 per cent to Mr. Shelley.

Summarizing the evidence just before sentence was passed, prosecutor Neil Saunders said Mr. Milsom tried to hide his tracks by using unregistered pay-as-you-go phones with different SIM cards to call Mr. Shelley.

The pair made over £400,000 from their arrangement, of which Mr. Milsom was paid about £164,000 in cash.

After his arrest, Mr. Milsom volunteered information to FSA investigators about a separate insider dealing arrangement he had with another independent broker between April 2008 and April 2009.

He revealed details of 15 transactions involving five stocks, resulting in a total profit of just over £160,000 of which Mr. Milsom received £81,000.

The name of the other broker was not disclosed in court.

Story continues below advertisement

The £245,000 Mr. Milsom was ordered to pay was the total he had received from the 28 deals with Mr. Shelley as well as the other 15 transactions.

The judge said he had taken into account several mitigating factors in passing sentence on Mr. Milsom. These included the ex-trader's early guilty plea and evidence that he was "loyal, hard-working and hitherto honest."

Operation Tabernula is part of a wider crackdown on market abuse by the FSA, which was criticized in the past for a light-touch style of regulation exposed as inadequate by the financial crisis.

Prior to Mr. Milsom's guilty plea, the FSA had already secured 21 convictions for insider trading.

It said Mr. Milsom's case should serve as an example to others working in financial services.

"His personal greed will have cost him his reputation, his career and his liberty. Those who think there is easy money to be made from insider dealing should think again," said Tracey McDermott, director of enforcement at the FSA.

Report an error

The Globe invites you to share your views. Please stay on topic and be respectful to everyone. For more information on our commenting policies and how our community-based moderation works, please read our Community Guidelines and our Terms and Conditions.

We’ve made some technical updates to our commenting software. If you are experiencing any issues posting comments, simply log out and log back in.

Discussion loading… ✨