Skip to main content

The Globe and Mail

Olympics blunder costs G4S British prison deals

Two soldiers walk through the Olympic Park in east London, July 14, 2012. G4S’s failure to provide enough security staff at Olympic venues forced an embarrassed government to draft in soldiers to cover the shortfall.


Security group G4S PLC missed out on contracts to run British prisons on Thursday, paying the price for embarrassing the government by failing to provide enough guards at the London Olympics.

The Ministry of Justice was widely expected to hand the majority of five contracts to manage seven state-run prisons to the private sector, but instead said it would keep three under public sector management after the bids failed to impress.

G4S missed the cut on deals to run six prisons, including Wolds in northern England, a prison which the company has managed since 1992 but which will now return to the public sector in July 2013.

Story continues below advertisement

French caterer Sodexo, British outsourcer Serco Group PLC and a venture between U.S. prisons firm MTC and Britain's Amey – owned by Spanish group Ferrovial SA – are in the running for the remaining two contracts to run Northumberland prison and three jails in South Yorkshire.

Coldingley, Durham and Onley prisons will remain under public sector management.

Media reports had suggested that contracts to run the eight prisons would have been worth as much as £2-billion ($3.20-billion U.S.) in total. Contracts for the prisons that remain in the bidding could be worth some £1.1-billion.

G4S, which runs six prisons in Britain, expressed disappointment at the announcement. Its shares were down by 5.2 per cent at midday.

It said it would discuss with the ministry why it was unsuccessful.

Investors had seen the contracts as a test of the state's appetite to continue working with G4S, whose failure to provide enough security staff at Olympic venues forced an embarrassed government to draft in soldiers to cover the shortfall.

Earlier this week chief executive Nick Buckles said he hoped G4S's track record in winning government work – which represents some 13 per cent of group revenue – would stand it in good stead for prison work.

Story continues below advertisement

"To us, it would suggest that the (G4S) business has incurred some reputational damage with the U.K. government following the London Olympic contract failure," Espirito Santo analyst David Brockton said.

Along with G4S – which sparked uproar from unions in March last year when it took over at Birmingham prison and became the first private firm to manage a state-run jail – American prison operator GEO Group and British support services and construction firm Interserve PLC also missed out.

The ministry of justice said outsourcing firm Mitie Group PLC, which had bid for all the contracts in partnership with the Prison Service, had also lost out.

Justice Secretary Chris Grayling said other prisons could be put out to private management on a case-by-case basis.

Faced with crowded prisons, high reoffending rates and austerity cuts the government has considered outsourcing in a bid to improve innovation across prisons, probation and youth services.

Electronic tagging contracts in England that could be worth as much as £1-billion are expected to be awarded in the middle of 2013, while some analysts have said it is possible that another 40 prisons could come to market.

Story continues below advertisement

Fourteen prisons are already run privately in Britain – three by Sodexo, six by G4S and five by Serco, with all others in England and Wales managed by the Prison Service. Serco has been running a payment by results pilot at Doncaster, whereby its income is contingent on it reducing reoffending rates.

Report an error

The Globe invites you to share your views. Please stay on topic and be respectful to everyone. For more information on our commenting policies and how our community-based moderation works, please read our Community Guidelines and our Terms and Conditions.

We’ve made some technical updates to our commenting software. If you are experiencing any issues posting comments, simply log out and log back in.

Discussion loading… ✨