Skip to main content

The Globe and Mail

Monsanto, DuPont strike $1.75-billion deal to settle patent dispute

The deal tosses out a $1-billion jury verdict DuPont was ordered to pay Monsanto in August for infringing its patent, in favour of royalty payments.


DuPont Co. has agreed to pay Monsanto Co. at least $1.75-billion (U.S.) to settle the rivals' bitter legal battles over rights to technology for genetically modified seeds while forging a new collaboration, the companies said on Tuesday.

The deal tosses out a $1-billion jury verdict DuPont was ordered to pay Monsanto in August for infringing its patents. Instead, the companies agreed that DuPont would make royalty payments of at least $1.75-billion over several years in exchange for broad access to develop products using Monsanto's leading genetic technology.

Monsanto shares rose nearly 4 per cent on the news, while DuPont shares fell nearly 1 per cent.

Story continues below advertisement

Still, DuPont officials said the agreement was a win for shareholders and sets up its Pioneer agricultural seed unit for future growth.

"This is a smart deal for DuPont," Paul Schickler, president of DuPont Pioneer, said in an interview. "We've got access to two additional technologies that we can now combine with our existing technologies as well as the technologies that are in our pipeline."

DuPont Pioneer will have broad rights to key new technology that include stacking of traits, Mr. Schickler said.

Monsanto, which generates revenues both through seed sales and licensing of its genetic seed technology to other companies, said the deal should bring in far more than the minimum $1.75-billion as DuPont pushes the company's technology through its broad customer base.

"We would expect them to move past those minimums pretty swiftly and significantly. They were and are the largest soybean company in the world, the United States for sure," said Scott Partridge, vice-president, strategy, for Monsanto. "We are pleased to have them again as a customer for our newest technology."

Under the agreement, which Mr. Schickler said came together over the last week, DuPont is to make four annual fixed royalty payments totalling $802-million to Monsanto from 2014 to 2017.

Beginning in 2018, DuPont will also pay royalties on a per-unit basis for Genuity Roundup Ready 2 Yield soybean technology and Genuity Roundup Ready 2 Xtend for the life of the agreement in exchange for continued technology access. Annual minimum payments through 2023 will total $950-million.

Story continues below advertisement

DuPont can start testing Monsanto's material in the field this year and will be able to sell Roundup Ready 2 Yield in 2014. And if regulatory approvals are in place, DuPont will be able to start selling the Xtend product in 2015, according to Mr. Schickler.

Pioneer will integrate the technology into its own seed germplasm over time, he said.

BGC Partners analyst Mark Gulley said the deal appears to be a win for both companies, notably for DuPont who has converted its legal liability for the $1-billion jury award into royalty payments that provide access to important new technology.

"Monsanto gets a nice royalty stream and DuPont gets to remove this cloud over the stock in terms of a contingent liability," he said.

Access to Xtend is key as it is seen as part of a next wave of herbicide-resistant crop technology aimed at dealing with a wave of herbicide-resistant weeds spreading across U.S. farmland.

The settlement comes after a jury in the U.S. District Court in St. Louis last year agreed with Monsanto that DuPont and Pioneer violated a licensing agreement for use of the Roundup Ready trait by trying to stack several traits together.

Story continues below advertisement

DuPont was pursuing a separate case against Monsanto, alleging anti-competitive behaviour, and a hearing in that matter was set for this autumn. But under the settlement, each side is dropping its claims against the other.

Both DuPont and Monsanto hold strong positions in the U.S. seed industry. They and other competitors have been racing to develop improved crops through genetic modifications and other means.

Pioneer, which generated sales of $7.3-billion in 2012, has been gaining market share in North American soybean and corn markets, and its brands have been popular with farmers.

Monsanto, which had $13.5-billion in sales last year, is seen as the market leader in developing genetically altered crop technology and is the world's largest seed company.

Monsanto introduced its Roundup Ready soybean technology in 1996. Roundup Ready crops can tolerate sprayings of Roundup, or glyphosate-based, herbicide. And the technology has become a foundation for many key crops, including corn, alfalfa, cotton, canola and sugar beets.

The two have been notorious for their battles, both in the marketplace and in the courtroom, but Monsanto's Mr. Partridge said on Tuesday that the companies had agreed to try to improve relations going forward.

"We do not want to have fights in the court house," he said. "We need to compete vigorously with our product offerings and let farmers choose."

Report an error

The Globe invites you to share your views. Please stay on topic and be respectful to everyone. For more information on our commenting policies and how our community-based moderation works, please read our Community Guidelines and our Terms and Conditions.

We’ve made some technical updates to our commenting software. If you are experiencing any issues posting comments, simply log out and log back in.

Discussion loading… ✨