Reuters Breakingviews delivers agenda-setting financial insight. Its global correspondents react to stories as they develop, delivering sharp and provocative commentary on big financial news as it breaks.
The fictitious adventures of Anastasia Steele and Christian Grey, the protagonists of the 50 Shades erotic trilogy may have spared Bertelsmann's management some nasty questions on declining profitability. The books' global success helped boost operating profit at the German media group's publishing unit, Random House, by 76 per cent to a record of €325-million ($424-million) – 19 per cent of group profit on only 13 per cent of its revenue.
This stunning performance hides several structural weaknesses at Bertelsmann, whose overall operating profit fell 1.1 per cent last year. The company still generates 80 per cent of its revenue in Europe, and it operates in many declining industries like gravure printing or the production of CDs and DVDs.
Apart from Random House, all of Bertelsmann's other divisions saw their profitability decline in 2012. Bertelsmann's EBITDA margin, at 13.7 per cent, is almost one third lower than that of German competitor Axel Springer AG. The company has warned that profit in 2013 could shrink further.
Bertelsmann lags behind in adapting to the digital age. While digital businesses at Axel Springer already generate 38 per cent of all profit, the group still makes most of its money from traditional businesses, notably its free-TV unit RTL Group, that are prone to future competition from the Internet.
After a lost decade, a new management team last year finally began the process of turning Bertelsmann into a more global, digital and faster-growing company. An intended merger of Random House with the U.K.'s Penguin is poised to create the world's leading consumer publisher. And the full integration of digital music rights management firm BMG secures a small but profitable and fast-growing digital business.
Further progress will be more difficult to achieve, partly due to Bertelsmann's limited financial firepower. The group is still resisting the idea of an IPO and now wants to fund its transition from the sale of a 17-per-cent share of RTL. However, RTL's stock market value has shrunk by a quarter since the plan was made public.
Given these limitations, Bertelsmann decided not to bid for the academic publisher Springer Science, valued at €3-billion to €4-billion. It is contemplating smaller acquisitions instead. That piecemeal approach spreads the risks but will also prolong the transition. In the meantime, Bertelsmann must keep hoping for yet another surprise bestseller.