Skip to main content

The Globe and Mail

China's EU support has strings best left unplucked

The European Central Bank building


It's no surprise that China's pledges of support for indebted trade partners come with strings. But Premier Wen Jiabao, addressing the World Economic Forum on Wednesday, was unusually blunt about what he expects in return: to be named by Europe as a market economy. That would cost Europe little – but that doesn't mean it should agree.

Chinese investment must look more appealing as stricken euro zone states like Italy, Greece and Spain face up to the possibility investors will refuse to finance their deficits. Italy's gouging by bond markets on Tuesday gives a taster. Just a drop of China's $3.2-trillion (U.S.) in foreign exchange reserves would give troubled countries a reprieve, and help lower their bond yields.

Market economy status is, on the face of it, an easy thing to give in return. After all, it's just a label. But without it, countries can accuse China of dumping goods, and then use other countries' prices – say, India's energy prices or Thailand's land costs – to prove their point. Under World Trade Organization rules, China gets market status anyway in 2016, but as Mr. Wen says, bringing that forward a few years is the kind of thing one might expect "from one friend to another."

Story continues below advertisement

Perhaps. Only China isn't a market economy – it's a "socialist market economy." Some important hallmarks aren't there. The exchange rate is guided more by policy than market forces. Capital is allocated by decree rather than just by price. True, China isn't the command economy it was under Chairman Mao. But the suppressed rate on deposits, for example, or the inflated lending rates for small companies, show that not everything is pure supply and demand.

So while Europe could give China what it wants – and it has flexed the "market" definition before for Russia – it's hardly a commendable course. Far better for Europe's leaders to get their own house in order, including planning for a Greek default and pushing Italy to cut back its debts. That might sound like harder work. But it would have the added appeal of making China's veiled ultimatums redundant.

Report an error
As of December 20, 2017, we have temporarily removed commenting from our articles. We hope to have this resolved by the end of January 2018. Thank you for your patience. If you are looking to give feedback on our new site, please send it along to If you want to write a letter to the editor, please forward to