A diversity report in the NFL assigned high grades for the league office but lagging scores at team levels for racial and gender hiring.
Wednesday’s report card from The Institute for Diversity and Ethics in Sport (TIDES) at Central Florida assigned an overall B-minus grade for the league, with a B-plus for racial hiring and a C for gender hiring. The report examined a range of positions at the league headquarters and within franchises using data for the 2020 season.
The league headquarters received an A-plus in racial hiring and a B in gender hiring. Richard Lapchick, TIDES director and lead report author, also praised the NFL for steps such as expanding the Rooney Rule with a resolution calling for draft picks to reward organizations that develop minority coaches and front-office executives to fill leadership positions at other teams.
“The big notable in this report is the league office has set a really good example, particularly on racial hiring but also on gender hiring,” Lapchick said in an interview with The Associated Press, adding: “I give a lot of credit to the league office this year for trying to move the needle.”
The overall racial score of 85.2 points climbed from 82.3 last year. Lapchick said that gain would have been greater if not for TIDES’s recent methodology change to add categories for team chief executive officers or presidents as well as team vice-presidents.
That also attributed to the overall gender score sliding from 76 points in 2019 to 73 points.
Grades were lower in top positions at team levels, including for head coaches and leadership roles for a sport in which the study reported 69.4 per cent of players are people of colour.
In racial hiring, league teams received a D-plus for head coaches with four minorities in Pittsburgh’s Mike Tomlin, Washington’s Ron Rivera, Los Angeles Chargers coach Anthony Lynn and Miami’s coach Brian Flores, joined later by interim coaches Romeo Crennel in Houston and Raheem Morris in Atlanta. Team racial-hiring grades also included a D for team CEOs or presidents and an F for GMs or the principal person in charge, with Miami general manager Chris Grier and Cleveland general manager Andrew Berry as the only GMs of colour to start the season.
Gender-hiring grades also lagged, with teams receiving an F for CEOs or presidents and team senior administration.
“I think that teams haven’t been as progressive as the league office has in terms of their hiring,” Lapchick said.
In a statement, the NFL said the study highlighted areas of improvement as well as “where we have fallen short and where we must do more.” The league said it continues to pursue diversity initiatives to benefit women and minorities.
“Diversity, equity, and inclusion are core values of our league; to ensure that we present a leadership at all levels that reflects and supports the extraordinary work that our players and coaches do every day,” the league said.
“We will not accomplish our goals in one season, and progress will not always be even and steady,” the league continued. “But our commitment is unwavering and the progress we have made since last year only strengthens our determination to continue to work every day to instil these values throughout all aspects of the league.”