The two-time defending Stanley Cup champions on one side. The Presidents’ Trophy winners on the other. Franchises separated by just a couple hundred miles of highway. And two teams that don’t like each other very much.
Tampa Bay and Florida. For the state championship – and so much more.
The Lightning and the Panthers are meeting in the playoffs for the second consecutive season, with Game 1 starting Tuesday on Florida’s home ice. Tampa Bay needed six games to oust the Panthers a year ago in Round 1.
“Florida is a hell of a team,” Tampa Bay coach Jon Cooper said. “We’ve watched them all year. We’ve had some amazing battles with them. I think people, especially in Florida, have been begging for the two teams to be contenders and go at it. Last year, many people said that might have been the series of the playoffs. They retooled their team and brought some big names in there and it should be a ton of fun.”
The Lightning won a Game 7 in Toronto to extend their hope of trying to become the first team to win three consecutive Stanley Cups since the New York Islanders won four in a row from 1980 through 1983. The Panthers are coming off their first series win in 26 years, beating Washington in six games, and now have a shot at avenging last season’s playoff loss.
“That’s when things get interesting and rivalries are born when you play teams multiple times in the playoffs now ... and we know what it’s going to be,” Lightning forward Steven Stamkos said. “That was one heck of a series last year in the first round.”
The NHL started awarding the Presidents’ Trophy in 1986 to the club with the best regular-season record, and this marks the ninth time in that span that the winner of that trophy has faced the reigning Cup champion in the playoffs.
Of the previous eight instances, the last of which came in 2017 when Washington lost in seven games to Pittsburgh, it’s a split – four wins for the Cup champs, four wins for the Presidents’ Trophy holders.
“They’re a great team,” Florida interim coach Andrew Brunette said. “They are who we want to be, and this is a great opportunity for us.”
The NHL’s records for postseason power-play percentage go back to the 1978 playoffs. Florida is at the bottom of that chart. Florida was 0 for 18 with the man advantage against the Capitals. The only teams that were worse in a postseason since 1978, the NHL said, were Winnipeg (0-28 vs. Detroit in 1996), Los Angeles (0-23 vs. Detroit in 2000), San Jose (0-22 vs. St. Louis in 2001), Calgary (0-21 vs. Chicago in 1996) and Buffalo (0-19 vs. Boston in 2010). All lost in Round 1. Tampa Bay has scored on 21.3 per cent of its power plays in franchise playoff history, best all-time of any team in the NHL. The Lightning were seven for 33 with the extra skater against Toronto in Round 1.
The Panthers and Lightning have met 156 previous times, more than they have faced any other club and that doesn’t include plenty of preseason matchups. Florida has 75 wins, Tampa Bay 71, and they tied 10 times when ties were still a thing. They split four games this season; Florida got five points out of the four matchups because one of its losses came in overtime. Florida needed three goalies in its series last year. But right now, Panthers netminder Sergei Bobrovsky – who went the whole way against Washington – looks very much like he was when he swept then-Presidents’ Trophy winner Tampa Bay out of the playoffs in 2019.
This marks the fourth time that there’s been an all-Florida postseason matchup in the NHL, NBA or NFL. The Lightning beat the Panthers last year, the Jacksonville Jaguars beat the Miami Dolphins on Jan. 15, 2000, and the Miami Heat beat the Orlando Magic in the first round of the 1997 playoffs.
South Florida is the only market left with teams in the NBA and NHL playoffs. The Miami Heat are in the Eastern Conference finals against the Boston Celtics. The Heat play about 45 minutes south of the Panthers’ home arena. Fans will have to choose who they want to see over the next week or two. The Heat and Panthers are both home Tuesday and Thursday, and Games 4 through 7 of both Heat-Celtics and Panthers-Lightning are scheduled to be on the same nights as well – with all four potential Florida home games set to possibly conflict with Heat home games.