Skip to main content

The Globe and Mail

Who should be in the 2013 Hockey Hall of Fame class?

It's safe to say there will likely be three names atop everyone's list for the Hockey Hockey of Fame next year. But as is always the case, there's certainly room for debate.

Here's a closer look at the three front-runners to be inducted into the class of 2013, as well as a few honourable mentions:

Brendan Shanahan

Story continues below advertisement

The big winger from Mimico, Ont., won three Stanley Cups and was twice on the first all-star team, with the bulk of his career split between New Jersey, St. Louis and Detroit.

Shanahan was an incredible goal-scorer above all else, and a player who reinvented himself to play more of a grinding role later in his career.

One great stat for the current NHL disciplinarian: After adjusting his career totals for the low-scoring era in which he played many of his seasons, has him as the sixth-highest goal-scorer of all-time.

Without any tweaking, he sits 13th in career NHL goals and games played, and 25th in career points.

Scott Niedermayer

A smooth-skating defenceman who grew up in Cranbrook, B.C., he won four Stanley Cups, a Memorial Cup, world junior gold, two Olympic gold medals, one James Norris Memorial Trophy, one Conn Smythe Trophy and was on the NHL's first all-star team three times.

Niedermayer may not have been a huge point producer (22nd all-time among defencemen) but was so effective in so many other ways that made him a huge part of winners in junior, the NHL and Olympics.

Story continues below advertisement

Chris Chelios

Known mainly late in his career for being the oldest player in the game, he was a star early in his career, winning three Stanley Cups, three Norris Trophies and making an impressive five first all-star teams. Chelios's longevity, however, certainly helps his Hall of Fame cause, as he is fifth in career games played and 10th in points by a defenceman (948).

Hard to argue with any of those three, especially given their credentials might even exceed those of three of the four players who were inducted last Monday.

Honourable mentions

Who else should be up for consideration?

Well, there's always the controversial choice of Eric Lindros, who suffered from the same shortened-career issues as 2012 inductee Pavel Bure but has numbers just as impressive and won a Hart Memorial Trophy.

Story continues below advertisement

Then, there are those who have waited even longer and/or are longer shots, from Dave Andreychuk to Phil Housley, Sergei Makarov, Rob Blake, Theo Fleury and several goaltenders (Tom Barrasso, Curtis Joseph, etc.).

You also have to add in builders such as legendary coaches Pat Burns and Fred Shero to consider – both of whom large factions of the hockey world has pushed to put in the Hall.

Not to mention the addition of more female players, who have been conspicuously absent since they were first granted separate induction in 2010.

The smart money for 2013?

Shanahan, Niedermayer and Chelios all go in, with a builder (Shero), and a female player (Canadian Olympian Geraldine Heaney).

By Hockey Hall of Fame standards, that's quite a class.

Report an error Licensing Options
About the Author
Hockey Reporter

James joined The Globe as an editor and reporter in the sports department in 2005 and now covers the NHL and the Toronto Maple Leafs. More


The Globe invites you to share your views. Please stay on topic and be respectful to everyone. For more information on our commenting policies and how our community-based moderation works, please read our Community Guidelines and our Terms and Conditions.

We’ve made some technical updates to our commenting software. If you are experiencing any issues posting comments, simply log out and log back in.

Discussion loading… ✨