A Minnesota judge has dismissed a third-degree murder charge filed against the former Minneapolis police officer who pressed his knee against George Floyd’s neck, saying there was not enough probable cause for that count to proceed to trial. The more serious second-degree murder charge against Derek Chauvin remains.
Hennepin County District Judge Peter Cahill’s ruling, dated Wednesday and made public Thursday, found probable cause for Mr. Chauvin to be tried on one count of unintentional second-degree murder and one count of second-degree manslaughter. Justice Cahill also found probable cause to move forward with the aiding and abetting counts against three other former officers, Thomas Lane, J. Kueng and Tou Thao.
“In this court’s view, with one exception, the State has met its burden of showing probable cause that warrants proceeding to trial against each of these Defendants on each of the criminal charges the State has filed against them,” Justice Cahill wrote. He said a jury will decide whether they are guilty.
Mr. Floyd, a Black man in handcuffs, died May 25 after Mr. Chauvin, who is white, pressed his knee against Mr. Floyd’s neck as he said he couldn’t breathe. Mr. Floyd’s death sparked protests in Minneapolis and beyond, and led to a nationwide reckoning on race. All four officers were fired. They are scheduled to stand trial in March.
After Justice Cahill’s ruling, Gov. Tim Walz activated the Minnesota National Guard in anticipation of protests. Protesters demonstrated in the streets after Mr. Chauvin was released on bail earlier this month, resulting in dozens of arrests.
On the second-degree murder charge, prosecutors presented probable cause to show Mr. Chauvin’s actions were a “substantial causal factor” in Mr. Floyd’s death, and that he was committing or attempting to commit another felony at the time, in this case, assault, Justice Cahill wrote.
He said prosecutors do not need to show Mr. Chauvin’s actions were the sole cause of Mr. Floyd’s death. He also said Mr. Chauvin’s decision to continue kneeling on Mr. Floyd’s neck after he went silent and motionless “is strong evidence of Mr. Chauvin’s intent to inflict bodily harm.”
But to prove a third-degree murder charge, prosecutors must show that Mr. Chauvin’s intentional conduct was “eminently dangerous to others” and not specifically directed at Mr. Floyd, Justice Cahill said.
“This is not an appropriate case for a third-degree murder charge,” he said.
While former Minneapolis police officer Mohamed Noor was convicted of third-degree murder in the 2017 killing of Justine Ruszczyk Damond, Justice Cahill said the cases are “factually distinguishable.” Mr. Noor fired a gun outside his squad car window, potentially endangering a nearby bicyclist, residents, possible bystanders, his partner, or others.
In this case, Justice Cahill said, “nothing about the manner in which Chauvin pressed his knee down on Floyd’s neck ... was eminently dangerous to anyone other than Floyd,” who was the target of Mr. Chauvin’s actions.
Attorney Ben Crump said in a statement that Mr. Floyd’s family is grateful most of the counts were preserved, including the more serious second-degree murder count, “for which we expect a conviction, based on the clear and evident use of excessive force that we all saw on video.”
Many legal observers initially believed the third-degree murder count wasn’t a good fit, and activists and family members had called for more serious charges.
Nicole Kettwick, a criminal defence attorney not associated with this case, said the dismissal of that count is not surprising because the facts currently known don’t fit the elements of the charge.
When the third-degree murder charge was filed, the Minnesota chapter of the American Civil Liberties Union asked the state to take over the case from Hennepin County, saying more serious charges were warranted. Attorney General Keith Ellison’s office is now the lead prosecutor on the case.
“The ACLU of Minnesota expected today’s ruling and believes it’s an appropriate step in this legal process,” ACLU of Minnesota executive director John Gordon said in a statement. “Today was a good day for achieving justice for George Floyd.”
Justice Cahill also found probable cause for the aiding and abetting charges to proceed against Mr. Lane, Mr. Kueng and Mr. Thao, saying they could be found criminally liable if prosecutors can prove they intentionally aided or conspired with Mr. Chauvin, and that they knew Mr. Chauvin was committing a crime at the time. He said prosecutors also must show that their presence or actions allowed the crime to continue.
Mr. Lane and Mr. Kueng heard Mr. Floyd say he couldn’t breathe, knew Mr. Chauvin was kneeling on Mr. Floyd’s neck, and heard the cries of the crowd, yet they continued to restrain Mr. Floyd by his legs and back, Justice Cahill said. The fact that Mr. Lane asked if Mr. Floyd should be rolled to a recovery position shows Mr. Lane knew “the consequences of keeping Floyd pinned face-down to the ground” but elected to “stay the course,” Justice Cahill said.
Mr. Lane never tried to extract himself from the situation or assertively tell Mr. Chauvin to stop, he said. Even if restraining Mr. Floyd was initially justified, that doesn’t grant the officers “carte blanche” to continue to restrain him without considering the changing circumstances, the judge said.
Mr. Lane and Mr. Kueng’s rookie status is irrelevant, he said: “There is no free pass under state law for rookies who choose to disregard their training at the suggestion of a senior officer.”
Justice Cahill said Mr. Thao never physically restrained Mr. Floyd, but could see and hear what was happening, and his actions to keep the crowd away allowed the restraint of Mr. Floyd to continue.
Our Morning Update and Evening Update newsletters are written by Globe editors, giving you a concise summary of the day’s most important headlines. Sign up today.