Go to the Globe and Mail homepage

Jump to main navigationJump to main content

(Andrew Vaughan)
(Andrew Vaughan)

Top Business Stories

RIM: When your stock's too cheap to short Add to ...

These are stories Report on Business is following Tuesday, Nov. 29. Get the top business stories through the day on BlackBerry or iPhone by bookmarking our mobile-friendly webpage.

Follow Michael Babad and Globe top business news on Twitter

Don't short RIM, analyst says Yesterday, two more analysts weighed in on the outlook for shares of Research In Motion Ltd. , one with a bleaker outlook, the other believing the stock is wildly oversold.

Today, there's another report, but this one with a twist. Berstein Research analyst Pierre Ferragu raised his rating on the shares, though trimmed his target, and warned against shorting the stock because the BlackBerry maker could become a takeover target.

“RIM is down 77 per cent since its highs of February this year and, although we do not change our fundamental views on the company we upgrade the stock,” he said.

“The company’s current challenges are now well understood by investors and we believe a failure of the current strategy is now well priced in and we see upside risks making a short position unwise today. In the medium term, as the failure of RIM’s current strategy becomes more obvious, we see shareholder activism leading to a change in management and a takeover - or at least the anticipation of it, as potential upsides making the risk-reward of a short position not attractive any more."

Microsoft Corp. or HTC could consider buying the company at some point, he said, though there's "no obvious buyer" today. Simply talk of a takeover could boost the stock, he said, though he's not recommending it.

"We nevertheless do not recommend buying RIM to play the above scenario before getting some evidence that a major change (credible activism, change in management attitude) is underway."

While Mr. Ferragu is downbeat on the company, like some other analysts, his report stands in stark contrast to the one issued yesterday by Gus Papageorgiou of Scotia Capital, who rates the shares as "outperform" and sees the company starting to turn the corner this quarter. It is profitable, and has 70 million global subscribers.

As well, Laszlo Birinyi of Birinyi Associates picked RIM as one of his 2012 winners on CNBC today.

“It’s been beaten down, it’s a brand, it’s got its fans, it’s got its products," he said. "In 1997, I was in the Year in Wall Street show, and Louis Rukeyser asked me what were my picks for 1998. I said my first pick is a $7 stock - called Apple Computer."

RIM has been in a heated race with the iPhone from Apple Inc. and devices run on the Android system from Google Inc. . Its latest quarterly results did not capture the impact of new models, and it reports next in mid-December.

RIM shares shot up today as the company unveiled an upgrade of its BlackBerry Enterprise Server to accommodate Apple and Android devices.

AMR in bankruptcy protection AMR Corp. and American Airlines have filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection, a move to "achieve a cost and debt structure that is industry competitive." Its shares collapsed after the announcement.

The huge American carrier, along among its peers in not being profitable last year, said its flights are running normally today. American has a code-sharing deal with WestJet Airlines Ltd. .

"After years of avoiding filing for bankruptcy, AMR decided that Chapter 11 was the best alternative to improving its cost and debt structure in order to increase its competitiveness," said Desjardins analyst Benoit Poirier.

AMR said it filed for a voluntary Chapter 11 restructuring in the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of New York, and hinted to its workers what is to come.

"As we have made clear with increasing urgency in recent weeks, we must address our cost structure, including labour costs, to enable us to capitalize on these foundational strengths and secure our future," said chief executive officer Thomas Horton.

"Our very substantial cost disadvantage compared to our larger competitors, all of which restructured their costs and debt through Chapter 11, has become increasingly untenable given the accelerating impact of global economic uncertainty and resulting revenue instability, volatile and rising fuel prices, and intensifying competitive challenges."

AMR won't hit Bombardier While AMR's Chapter 11 filing is far from good news, there's not expected to be a hit to Bombardier Inc. , Mr. Poirier of Desjardins said today.

"In our view, American Airlines’ bankruptcy is not an indication of airline profitability in general, but a reflection of company-specific factors," he said in a research note.

"Recall that IATA forecasts that North American airlines will make a profit of $1.2-billion in 2012 (down from $1.5-billion in 2011). North American load factor stood at 82.3 per cent in October - although down slightly from 83 per cent last year, it remains the highest load factor in the world."

Where Bombardier is concerned, he sees no direct impact.

"American Eagle, AMR’s regional subsidiary, has an active fleet of 245 aircraft that includes 47 CRJ700s (22 of which were delivered in 2010 and 2011), 198 Embraer regional jets and 36 ATR turboprop aircraft. Of note, Bombardier does not have backlog exposure to AMR."

BHP reviews diamond business BHP Billiton is reviewing its diamond operations in Canada, warning it could pull out.

BHP has interests in the Ekati diamond mine - it holds 80 per cent - about 200 kilometres south of the Arctic Circle - and also has the Chidliak exploration project in Nunavut. Over the past three years, the Ekati mine has produced an average of more than 3 million carats of rough diamonds annually. That represents about 10 per cent of the global supply when measured by value, BHP said.

But the mining giant said today it's trying to determine whether it's worth it, given that "many years of extensive exploration suggest there are few options to develop new diamond mines" consistent with its strategy of investing in big projects with long lives.

"This review will, therefore, examine whether a continued presence in the diamonds industry is consistent with BHP Billiton’s strategy and evaluate the potential sale of all or part of the diamonds business."

Auto investment loses steam Canada's auto industry is losing steam in the global race for investment as the car industry rebounds from its crisis, a new report suggests.

Though the Canadian industry continues to recover from the financial crisis and recession, investment will shrink to just $1.2-billion this year, warns the study from senior economist Carlos Gomes, The Globe and Mail's Richard Blackwell reports. That's the lowest since the mid-1980s, and more than 60 per cent below the annual average of $3.1-billion over the past 10 years.

The industry is strong in Canada in terms of ratings, and will hold on to its traditional 16 per cent of North American production, but "current investment plans are less positive for Canadian plants, suggesting that it will be difficult for Canada to increase its share of North American output going forward."

The auto industry has long been a manufacturing powerhouse for Ontario, and today's report by Mr. Gomes suggests the province's factory sector will still struggle to keep pace with other industries. It comes as Ottawa studies what to do about the auto sector.

On a per-vehicle basis, investment in Canada's auto industry this year will shrink to 43 per cent below that of the United States.

That's a dramatic turnaround given that the trend over the past 10 years was that it ran 3 per cent above the levels in the United States and Mexico.

And a note for the Canadian auto workers union: Mr. Gomes says that U.S. investment is gaining partly because U.S. workers won more investment for their plants in the lates round of labour talks.

Mortgage debt eases Canadians are slowing down when it comes to mortgage debt, a good sign for the country's real estate market.

The growth of mortgage debt has significantly decelerated since March, particularly in recent months, Canada Mortgage and Housing Corp. said today, The Globe and Mail's Tara Perkins reports.

At the same time, CMHC said its analysis suggests house prices are in line with demographic changes and economic growth.

Nexen in shale deal Canada's Nexen Inc. has struck a $700-million deal to develop its northwestern B.C. shale gas properties with a major Japanese player in the industry.

Nexen is selling a 40-per-cent working stake to INPEX Corp. in a deal that would also see a liquefied natural gas export terminal on the west coast, The Globe and Mail's Shawn McCarthy reports.

This is the latest among several agreements to bring Asian investors into Canada's oil and gas industry.

Nexen also unveiled a 2012 plan that raised some eyebrows in the investment community.

"While we see the transaction as positive, with the dual benefits of recouping sunk capital and providing a capital investment carry, the range of production expectations from Buzzard is greater than we were expecting," said analyst George Toriola of UBS Securities Canada. "We also see higher than expected expenditures at Long Lake in ramping up the production volumes."

German firm to proceed with potash project Germany’s K+S AG, Europe's largest potash producer, said today it will move forward with construction of its $3.2-billion Legacy project in Saskatchewan, The Globe and Mail's Brenda Bouw reports.

K+S, which obtained the project a year ago in the $434-million purchase of Canada’s Potash One, said production is expected to begin in 2015.

Britain warns of tough times The pain overseas is by no means limited to the euro zone.

Britain's Chancellor George Osborne said today that he doesn't expect another recession, but that's not to say the economy won't slide back again if Europe's debt crisis continues to rage.

Presenting his autumn economic and fiscal forecast in parliament, Mr. Osborne said the economy will expand 0.9 per cent this year, fall to 0.7 per cent next year, and then rebound to 2.1 per cent in 2013, The Globe and Mail's Eric Reguly reports.

He admitted that the growth slowdown means Britain will be unable to reach its target of eliminating the structural deficit by 2015.

Italy pays high cost Setting the stage for a meeting of EU finance ministers today, Italy pulled off a debt auction, but at a steep price.

Rome sold almost €8-billion in paper, but yields were closing in on 8 per cent.

"European debt auctions went reasonably well this morning, but at least in Italy’s case, the yield being demanded is punishingly high enough to push the country further in the direction of unsustainable pressures," said Derek Holt and Karen Cordes Woods of Scotia Capital.

Bradbury goes digital If one needed proof of the growing popularity of e-readers and tablets, take note that even Ray Bradbury is now on board at the age of 91.

Mr. Bradbury, who derided the e-thing, agreed to the release of Fahrenheit 451 as an e-book, publisher Simon & Schuster said today.

"The publication in digital form comes as part of a new publishing agreement that includes all English language print and digital formats of Fahrenheit 451 in North America, and also includes English language mass market rights in North America to Bradbury’s The Martian Chronicles and The Illustrated Man," the publisher said.

Simon & Schuster noted that the 1953 novel - book burning in a futuristic society - has topped the 10 million mark and has been translated into 33 languages. It has never been out of print.

Lawyers, bankers under the gun To borrow from Elvis, it may very well be a Blue Christmas for lawyers and investment bankers in the United States, according to The Wall Street Journal.

The newspaper reported today that the New York firm of Cravath, Swaine & Moore LLP told its associate lawyers that this year's bonuses will largely be held to last year's versions, which, while above the 2009 level, are down markedly from the heady year that was 2007.

Traditionally, the Journal said, Cravath sets the tone for other major firms.

Yesterday, the newspaper reported on the latest study by Options Group, which found that those at the major Wall Street banks could find their annual pay sinking by up to 30 per cent from last year. That would see pay levels at their lowest since the financial crisis.

Bonuses alone could sink by up to 40 per cent, the study showed. Now, before you go crying, consider that a top bond trader will probably earn up to $1.8-million (U.S.) this year.

Business ticker

In Economy Lab The next time a political party vows to defend the interests of the producers in a certain industry, you should ask why it isn’t choosing to defend the interests of consumers instead, Stephen Gordon writes.

In International Business A Canadian-Chilean mining consortium involving Barrick Gold Corp. has filed for arbitration in a dispute over one of the world's richest deposits of gold and copper in the remote hills along Pakistan's western border, Graeme Smith reports from Istanbul.

In Globe Careers Employees routinely claim that any perceived mistreatment at work amounts to a legal claim. They are often mistaken, says Daniel Lublin.

From today's Report on Business

Report Typo/Error


Next story




Most popular videos »

More from The Globe and Mail

Most popular