Skip to main content

The Globe and Mail

Manitoba Liberals face increased internal criticism ahead of general meeting

Manitoba Liberal Party leader Rana Bokhari, in a photo taken from her official Facebook page.

This should be a celebratory time for the Manitoba Liberals – they're riding at a near record-high level in opinion polls under new leader Rana Bokhari heading into next month's annual general meeting.

But the party is dealing with another public eruption of internal criticism accusing Ms. Bokhari and her leadership team of stomping on the rights of grassroots members and, despite the improved popularity, of hurting the party.

"If this leadership group were trying to destroy the party, it could not be doing a better job," Shane Nestruck, president of the party's constituency association in Fort Garry-Riverview, told The Canadian Press on Monday.

Story continues below advertisement

"The only reason I am not resigning is that I hope for a complete change of leadership at the coming annual general meeting."

Mr. Nestruck's criticism echoes comments in February from Bob Axworthy, who ran against Ms. Bokhari for the leadership last October and who accused her and Liberal executives of "purging" some long-time members in an attempt to control the party.

Mr. Nestruck came forward after an anonymous blog surfaced online last week that was severely critical of Ms. Bokhari. The blog has since been taken down.

The party issued letters in February to a half-dozen members, including Mr. Nestruck, telling them their membership was under review and offering no explanation.

Mr. Nestruck said Ms. Bokhari's leadership team is trying to centralize power, which he feels belongs with the grassroots and the board of directors.

Liberal officials deny the accusations.

Some of the membership reviews were for people who had made controversial statements on social media during and after last year's heated leadership race, which saw Bokhari beat Dougald Lamont and Axworthy, said executive director Jeff Kovalik-Plouffe.

Story continues below advertisement

Those same statements are part of the reason for the reworked code of conduct.

"There was some sniping back and forth during the leadership [race] on Facebook with some people, and they were spoken to," he said.

"When people may be saying things that could be construed as racist or sexist or defamatory, as a party we have to take actions like that seriously."

The Liberals have one seat in the legislature and captured 7.5 per cent of the vote in the 2011 provincial election. Recent opinion polls suggest their support now tops 20 per cent, as approval for the governing New Democrats sinks. But the party continues to have challenges.

Membership is down to about 700 from 2,100 during last fall's leadership race, Mr. Kovalik-Plouffe said. Provincial memberships expire every December, and the Liberals are still working on renewals.

The party has had to get approval for a $70,000 overdraft to cover expenses in the short term. The Liberals spent a fair bit of money on two by-elections in January and are waiting for a 50-per-cent rebate from Elections Manitoba.

Story continues below advertisement

Minutes of a March 3 board of directors meeting, obtained by The Canadian Press, show the party "did not raise as much as was originally expected" from two major events last year.

"We have roughly $11,000 in our bank account," the minutes read.

"At this time, we are spending approximately $10,600 a month."

"Rana continues and states not one board member showed up to help on the by-elections and she states that was disturbing; would have hoped board members would attend," the documents states.

Mr. Nestruck said he expects some Liberals will challenge Ms. Bokhari at the annual general meeting to be held May 2 and 3 in Winnipeg.

Report an error
As of December 20, 2017, we have temporarily removed commenting from our articles. We hope to have this resolved by the end of January 2018. Thank you for your patience. If you are looking to give feedback on our new site, please send it along to If you want to write a letter to the editor, please forward to