One of the account's most popular posts compared what you could buy in Black Rock Cay, Honduras for $1.8-million versus what you could get in Toronto for the same price. In Honduras, that price nets you a private island and home. In Toronto, a tear down semi.Private Islands Inc.
As prices remain stubbornly high in Canada’s hottest real estate markets some young social media users are finding new ways to highlight what they view as the absurd choices facing new home buyers.
Take the example of @millennialmoron – he refuses to divulge his real name – who posts videos on Instagram and TikTok, and who fully appreciates his social media handle will invite derision. He recently created a video series called “Private Islands vs. Canadian Real Estate,” that started with a promise/threat: “Are you frustrated with the high prices of Canadian real estate? Well, prepare to be more frustrated.”
His most popular video was actually his second where he detailed Black Rock Cay in Honduras, a private island that was listed for $1.8-million. The island came with two boats, an updated main house, two guest cabanas, all the furnishings and all the mechanical and water equipment needed for island living. The @millennialmoron video contrasted that to a $1.8-million semi-detached house in Toronto at 54 Stewart St. that didn’t have quite the same amenity package: there’s no toilet in the main bath, the backyard is a junk heap and the kitchen is missing some walls and part of the ceiling. What it has going for it is location: At King and Bathurst streets, it’s likely just a land parcel of a future condominium development.
The 54 Stewart St. house in Toronto, for sale for $1.8-million.visualadvantage.ca
Not that everyone gets the joke: there are many, many commenters on his posts who accuse him of all manner of things. He has had to post videos clearly disclaiming that he is A) not a realtor nor offering real estate advice B) not suggesting there is any real comparable between the upkeep costs of a home in a Canadian city and an island almost anywhere else and C) that his posts are satire, jokes and possibly funny.
“This isn’t a fair comparison … and it’s not a new idea, it’s just a specific comparison,” he said in a conversation with The Globe and Mail. Though he says he’s not ready to share his real name, he makes no effort to obscure his face on his deadpan send-ups of Canadian property prices. What drives his videos is a deep sense that something’s wrong with affordability in real estate. “I’m in my mid-thirties. I wouldn’t say there’s anyone in my age group who hasn’t talked about this issue,” he said. “We’ve seen houses go from completely reasonably priced to something that’s wildly out of reach.”
He says it all started a few years ago when he saw a couple of news stories about essentially teardown properties selling for millions of dollars in Canadian cities based primarily on land value. About a week ago he decided to crack a few jokes online about another of those homes making the rounds and he wanted to compare it to something really absurd. “What’s the most ludicrously luxurious property you could buy, something not even regular rich people have?” he asked himself. The answer: private islands.
In about a week he’s collected almost 20,000 followers and his most popular videos have collected tens or hundreds of thousands of views. So far he’s profiled islands in Argentina, Brazil, Ireland and closer to home in Wisconsin. He also detoured to compare a $4-million Vancouver single-family home to a castle on 32 acres England for about the same price.
The videos often rely on listings from Privateislandsonline.com, a site maintained by self-proclaimed “Isla-maniac” Chris Krolow of Private Islands Inc., who while not a realtor has built a business helping connect people to private islands for sale. He even co-created a TV show with cable channel HGTV called Island Hunters (there are five seasons so far) and is looking to do another island-themed show soon.
“I call myself an island broker, but I also come up with ideas and help clients through problems so I’m doing a lot of consulting: I go to a lot of places and I’m like what the heck were they thinking,” Mr. Krolow said.
Real island hunting comes with dangerous shoals – particularly if the island is undeveloped – and buyers need to understand what the buried costs of a given island are. On his own island he developed in Belize Mr. Krolow spends hundreds in fuel every time he uses his boat to come the mainland meaning a trip for groceries can cost up to $550.
“If you need full-time staff that’s really the big leap for costs. In the Bahamas if you need staff you’re looking at US$80,000 for a live-in caretaker,” he said. “One island that was listed at $10-million sold for $6-million and the owner didn’t seem to care about doing things with solar, so he spent about $800,000 a year on maintenance: Most of that was diesel fuel and full-time staff.”
Drawing an unfavourable contrast between Canadian real estate and international options is a familiar trope, and @millennialmoron’s videos hearken back a decade ago to the work of Toronto-based tech worker Melissa Hart who for a few years published a blog called FML Listings. She appeared in Canadian magazines and newspapers as a spokesperson for a generation sick of seeing properties in Willowdale (a Toronto inner suburb) sell for the same price as mansions in Malibu, Calif.
She never found an island that was comparable to Toronto real estate though.
“I did one to a château in France, in Bordeaux: it had a vineyard, it was an estate, and it was like hundreds of thousands less than a tiny house in Trinity Bellwoods [a downtown Toronto neighbourhood],” she said.
Worse, the prices that drove Ms. Hart to despair a decade ago look quaint by today’s standards. “I thought $500,000 should get you a semi – that was nine years ago. Now $500,000 is a down payment,” she said. “I was really cynical about the whole thing, and pessimistic, but even in my negative mindset I never thought it would get where it is now. I saw a one-bedroom condominium on MLS yesterday – 700 square feet in the Junction – it was $1.4-million.”
Ms. Hart stopped publishing her blog when she had her first child, but her real estate story did have a happy ending of sorts: though she was born and raised in the big city she and her partner eventually bought a house … about 45 minutes north of Toronto.
@millennialmoron also owns a home, in British Columbia, which he feels grateful to have. “My wife and I are both professionals and we were able to buy a modest house. Not what you would expect two people in our careers to have, but relative to everyone else struggling, we’re not on the brink,” he said.
Shane Dingman