Skip to main content

The Globe and Mail

Manufacturing faces bleak future as Caterpillar plant closes down

Caterpillar equipment sits on the lot at a dealership in London, Ont., home to a locomotive plant that is now closing.

Dave Chidley/The Canadian Press

The closing of a locomotive plant in London, Ont., by U.S. heavy equipment maker Caterpillar comes as the latest blow to Canada's struggling manufacturing sector.

Facing new competition from low-cost countries, a sluggish economic recovery and no longer able to count on a weak loonie to create a cost advantage, the sector faces a tough future.

Michael Burt, director for industrial economic trends at the Conference Board of Canada, said the manufacturing sector has been improving since the lows of the 2008-09 recession, but noted it faced difficulties long before the downturn.

Story continues below advertisement

"Before the recession, we saw no growth in broad manufacturing activity for much of the last decade," he said pointing to the rising loonie and China's growing role as the world's factory as two key factors.

Mr. Burt said there have been some areas of growth in areas such as food manufacturing, but the more traditional segments such as the auto-parts industry have struggled in the face of competition from places like Mexico.

"That's been because we are a higher-cost market. That's a function of the strengthening dollar and the unit labour costs in the industry."

Ten years ago, Canada's dollar was worth as little as 61.79 cents (U.S.). Now the two currencies are worth about the same, taking away one reason for companies to do their manufacturing in this country.

Caterpillar subsidiary Progress Rail Services announced Friday it would close the Electro-Motive Diesel plant in London after failing to reach a deal with its workers.

Progress Rail had asked the workers to take a 50-per-cent pay cut to help keep Electro-Motive going before locking them out on Jan. 1 after the union rejected the proposal.

The company, which bought Electro-Motive for $820-million (U.S.) in cash from Berkshire Partners LLC and Greenbriar Equity Group LLC in 2010, said it would move the work to its other plants in North and South America.

Story continues below advertisement

In addition to the operation in London, Progress has plants across the United States as well as in Mexico and Brazil.

The latest closure follows a decision last year by Navistar International Corp. to close its truck manufacturing plant in nearby Chatham, Ont., for good, a move that put 1,100 workers out of work.

Thousands of workers in the auto industry were thrown off the job during the restructuring of the big North American auto makers, which saw plants closed and others slimmed down.

Prime Minister Stephen Harper had used Electro-Motive as a backdrop in 2008 to promote big tax breaks for industrial capital investments.

NDP MP Robert Chisholm called on the federal government, which has said repeatedly that the Electro-Motive dispute is one between a private company and its workers, to do something.

"The fact is that taxpayers have funded Caterpillar, the growth of Caterpillar in this country," Mr. Chisholm said. "In fact, we're funding the move of Caterpillar to the United States and, so I say, and I think Canadians would agree, that this government has a responsibility to hold that company accountable."

Story continues below advertisement

Andrew MacDougall, a spokesman for Mr. Harper, challenged Mr. Chisholm's claim that taxpayers funded the Electro-Motive plant, adding that he wasn't aware of any government dollars having gone to Caterpillar.

He said the Prime Minister was disappointed with the outcome of the labour dispute and sympathized with the workers who are now without jobs. But he blamed the provincial government for not being able to mediate a solution.

Mr. MacDougall said Ottawa is working on a plan that will generate new jobs and opportunities for those affected by the closure and will also work with Ontario to provide access to benefits and skills training for displaced workers.

The CAW said Friday the closing of the factory did not just affect the plant's 465 workers, but would also hurt an additional 1,700 workers employed in spinoff jobs related to the operation.

The hit comes as the CAW prepares for a new set of contract talks with the U.S. auto makers. The union has said it is expecting a difficult round of bargaining.

The CAW has pointed to the erosion of the manufacturing sector in Canada and high unemployment as key challenges for workers across the country, both unionized and non-unionized and in both the private and public sector.

Mr. Burt said that the manufacturing growth in Canada in the 1990s was counter to what else was happening the rest of the world as the country benefited from the free-trade agreement with the United States and a weak loonie.

Report an error
Comments are closed

We have closed comments on this story for legal reasons. For more information on our commenting policies and how our community-based moderation works, please read our Community Guidelines and our Terms and Conditions.