Skip to main content

When the winner of the 20th anniversary Donner Prize is announced in Toronto on May 15, the result won’t necessarily send readers scrambling to the shelves for the best Canadian book on public policy. “Fifty-thousand dollars [for the winner] certainly beats the hell out of the royalties,” says Philip Cercone, executive director of McGill-Queen’s University Press, the publisher that boasts the most nominations in the prize’s history, including two on this year’s shortlist.

For the shortlisted researchers and academics, much more is at stake than prize money or modest bumps in sales: “It’s the ultimate recognition among their peers that they have done a work that is both substantial and will have an impact on society,” Cercone says.

This year’s five-person jury was generally “looking for something written in a way that is accessible,” chair David Dodge said in an interview. “As a former deputy minister and governor of the Bank [of Canada] who used this kind of stuff in my life, I find it just extraordinarily valuable. And the more and better quality folks we can induce to write this kind of book, the better off public servants, minsters and other people responsible for public policy are going to be.”

The following five books from the past year represent those the jury thinks can play an important role in future public policy discussions in Canada.

Open this photo in gallery:


In Charte canadienne et droits linguistiques: Pour en finir avec les myths, the sole French-language book on the shortlist – the award unusually considers works in Canada’s two official languages on a single list – Frédéric Bérard aims to reconsider the Charter of Rights and Freedoms’ effect on language rights. Analyzing laws, regulations and Supreme Court decisions, Bérard argues that the Charter has not in fact resulted in systematic bias against French language rights in Quebec. If it wins, this would be only the second French-language book to do so.

Open this photo in gallery:

In Pushing the Limits: How Schools Can Prepare our Children Today for the Challenges of Tomorrow, Kelly Gallagher-Mackay and Nancy Steinhauer ask how we can educate children to meet the technological, economic, social and political changes of an unknown future. They share stories from schools across Canada that are teaching children to, as Gallagher-Mackay says, “apply basic skills to real-world problems, to take risks and explore creativity, develop their social-emotional skills and have a rich sense of citizenship.” If Pushing the Limits takes the prize, it will be only the third time in the prize’s history that a female author has won.

Open this photo in gallery:

Stumbling Giants: Transforming Canada’s Banks for the Information Age is, in co-author Patricia Meredith’s words, “a call to action for all interested stakeholders – policy makers, regulators, customers, suppliers, investors and bankers – to work together to create a banking system for the 21st century.” Meredith and co-author James L. Darroch argue that, though Canadian banks emerged from the 2008 financial crisis as “a safe harbour in the financial storm,” the rapid adoption of mobile technologies such as ApplePay has seen their role in everyday financial transactions diminished. “The time has come,” says Meredith, for the banks “to respond to the socio-technological disruptors threatening the industry.”

Open this photo in gallery:

In Governing Public-Private Partnerships, Joshua Newman argues that the secret to successfully delivering public services is “for the government to stay involved as a central authority, a power broker, a strategic leader and a long-term planner.” Newman uses two examples of collaborative public/private projects in urban transportation – Vancouver’s Canada Line and Australia’s Sydney Airport Rail Link – to demonstrate that the state can and must remain involved in the building of infrastructure and the delivery of public services.

Open this photo in gallery:

In Too Critical to Fail: How Canada Manages Threats to Critical Infrastructure, co-authors Kevin Quigley, Ben Bisset and Bryan Mills take an analytical look at how Canada’s critical infrastructure is prepared to respond to what they call “black swans,” which they describe as “low-probability/high-consequence disasters with elements of randomness and bad luck.” The book is dedicated to the 47 people who died in the 2013 Lac-Mégantic disaster and considers that tragedy alongside other black swans such as the Alberta floods of 2013 and the 2009 H1N1 flu pandemic in its research.

Asked about the importance of the Donner Prize mandate, MQUP’s Cercone said that, in an era of fake news concerns, he feels it is becoming more important than ever.

“The only way you can fight this kind of mentality is to have well-researched books that are both rigorous and penetrable by the educated public,” he says. “And we need to have an educated public that hopefully goes out there and votes.”

Becky Toyne is the “Should I Read It?” columnist for Day 6 on CBC Radio and a regular contributor to Globe Books.

Interact with The Globe