Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre rises during Question Period in the House of Commons on Parliament Hill in Ottawa on March 31.PATRICK DOYLE/The Canadian Press
The Opposition Conservatives are asking Twitter to apply a “government-funded” label on accounts associated with the CBC, even as other broadcasters decry the tag for not making clear their editorial independence.
On Tuesday, Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre tweeted a copy of a letter addressed to the company making the request.
In the letter, Mr. Poilievre asked that the label be applied to CBC’s English “news-related” accounts. But he did not mention Radio-Canada, the broadcaster’s French-language arm.
The social-media giant currently defines “government-funded” media as outlets that “may have varying degrees of government involvement over editorial content.”
Mr. Poilievre said he believes that applies to CBC.
But CBC said in a statement on Wednesday that is “clearly not the case,” adding that it cannot comment on the motives behind Mr. Poilievre’s letter.
“As every Canadian knows, CBC/Radio-Canada is publicly funded. Its editorial independence is protected in law in the Broadcasting Act,” a spokesperson for the broadcaster said.
The office of Heritage Minister Pablo Rodriguez said the way the broadcaster’s public funding works, members of Parliament only vote on the sum of money it receives – they don’t guide its editorial decisions.
“It is an independent, arms-length Crown corporation,” said Laura Scaffidi, Mr. Rodriguez’s press secretary.
She called Mr. Poilievre’s comments an “attack on journalists.”
Other media outlets have raised concerns about the difference between phrases such as “government-funded” and “publicly funded” and what each implies.
Why Twitter’s new labels caused CBC, NPR to stop using the platform
After initially labelling BBC and National Public Radio as “state-affiliated” – a term usually reserved for government-run propaganda outlets in countries such as Russia and China – the platform shifted its language to “government-funded.”
With the British broadcaster continuing to find fault with that phrasing, Twitter made yet another change on Wednesday to call the BBC “publicly funded.”
Elon Musk, who owns the platform, had promised the shift in approach during an interview with BBC on Twitter Spaces on Tuesday.
Mr. Musk said that if Twitter used “the same words that the BBC uses to describe itself, that presumably would be OK,” and that he respects the broadcaster, which is funded by the British public through a licensing fee.
FRIENDS, a public broadcasting advocacy group, said Mr. Poilievre seems to have zero qualms about comparing CBC to the likes of Russia’s Sputnik TV.
“These tactics are irresponsible, dangerous and undermine the democracy that public institutions like CBC/Radio-Canada are desperately trying to uphold.”
NPR announced Wednesday that it would quit using Twitter after its accounts were inaccurately labelled. The United States public radio outlet said its credibility was being undermined by the platform “falsely implying that we are not editorially independent.”
NPR does receive U.S. government funding through grants from federal agencies and departments, along with the Corporation for Public Broadcasting. But the company said that accounts for less than one per cent of NPR’s annual operating budget.
“We are not putting our journalism on platforms that have demonstrated an interest in undermining our credibility and the public’s understanding of our editorial independence,” a spokesperson for NPR said Wednesday in a statement.
It’s the first major news outlet to make such a decision following Mr. Musk’s takeover of Twitter last year, with the social-media company facing new scrutiny over how it filters out the spread of false information.
The platform also recently stripped the New York Times of its verification check mark, with the newspaper saying it would not pay a monthly fee to maintain it.
CBC said it hasn’t made a decision yet on whether it will continue to use Twitter if the company decides to label it as “government funded,” saying it cannot comment on hypotheticals.
In 2021-22, the CBC received more than $1.2-billion in government funding, a decrease from about $1.4-billion in 2020-21.
CBC also makes money through advertising, subscriptions and syndication.