First Financial Indiana Announces CFO Retirement and Successor
First Financial Indiana ( (THFF) ) has provided an update.
On September 17, 2026, First Financial Corporation announced that longtime Chief Financial Officer and Secretary/Treasurer Rodger A. McHargue will retire on December 31, 2026, concluding a tenure as CFO that began in 2010. During his time in the role, McHargue was credited by management with helping drive strategic initiatives, meaningful growth and a stronger financial foundation for the bank holding company.
The Board has appointed Paul D. Nungester, currently Senior Vice President and Director of Finance, to succeed McHargue as CFO effective January 1, 2027, under an employment agreement running through June 30, 2028. Nungester brings nearly three decades of finance leadership experience, including prior CFO responsibilities at another financial institution, and his hiring underscores First Financial’s focus on continuity in its financial strategy and stable executive succession for shareholders and other stakeholders.
The most recent analyst rating on (THFF) stock is a Hold
with a $84.00 price target.
To see the full list of analyst forecasts on First Financial Indiana stock,
see the THFF Stock Forecast page.
Spark’s Take on THFF Stock
According to Spark, TipRanks’ AI Analyst, THFF is a Neutral.
The score is driven primarily by solid financial performance (strong profitability and TTM cash generation) tempered by higher balance-sheet leverage. Valuation is supportive with a low P/E and decent yield, while technical indicators are the main near-term drag due to weak momentum below key short-term moving averages. Corporate events are net positive, led by continued dividends and a growth-oriented merger, but with execution/approval risk.
To see Spark’s full report on THFF stock,
click here.
More about First Financial Indiana
First Financial Corporation, headquartered in Terre Haute, Ind., is the holding company for First Financial Bank, N.A., one of the oldest national banks in the U.S. The institution operates 87 banking centers across Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky and Tennessee, focusing on regional banking services for retail and commercial customers.
Through its multi-state footprint and long operating history, First Financial targets community and regional banking markets, emphasizing traditional banking products, credit services and deposit-taking. Its operations position the company as a longstanding player in the Midwest and Southeast financial services landscape.
Average Trading Volume: 113,664
Technical Sentiment Signal: Buy
Current Market Cap: $1.24B
Learn more about THFF stock on TipRanks’ Stock Analysis page.
