Skip to main content

Alberta Alberta’s election platforms compared: Where the NDP and UCP stand on everything from child care to carbon taxes

Albertans will be thinking about pipelines and the province’s sputtering economy when they vote. Campaign promises and homophobic, racist and other intolerant remarks by candidates have done little to shake the narrative.

Frustration and anger over the failure to build a new outlet for oil and gas, as well as four years of economic hardship, have dominated a dark campaign. United Conservative Leader Jason Kenney has vowed to fight Alberta’s “enemies” while NDP Leader Rachel Notley has called for diplomacy. Within days, the heart of Canada’s energy industry will be in the hands of one of the two leaders.

Both parties have laid out extensive fiscal plans that chart different paths for Alberta’s future – neither calls for a dramatic break with the present, through a sales tax or a pivot away from oil and gas. However, much is at stake, as both parties offer differing views on how to stoke economic growth and whether Canada’s unity question should migrate from Quebec to Alberta.

Story continues below advertisement

Pipelines

UCP

Mr. Kenney has vowed to see through the completion of the Trans Mountain and Keystone XL expansions. He’s also said he wants to restart talks to build the Energy East and Northern Gateway pipelines. The UCP Leader has proposed an aggressive strategy to see that through. His government would file constitutional challenges against Ottawa and would enact legislation to stop oil flows to B.C. as a form of punishment if pipelines aren’t built.

He’s also said he would hold a referendum in 2021 to remove equalization from the constitution if “substantial progress” is not made on the construction of a coastal pipeline.

The UCP would also create a war room with a $30-million annual budget to run advertising and defend Alberta’s oil and gas on social media. Mr. Kenney has also said he will sue groups that have fought the energy industry, including the David Suzuki Foundation.

NDP

Ms. Notley said she expects Trans Mountain will get federal approval before the end of May. Construction on the first pipeline to the Pacific Ocean since the Korean War would start soon after. Instead of cutting off oil to B.C., Ms. Notley has insisted a soft approach has swayed the majority of Canadians, saying seven out of 10 are now in support of Trans Mountain.

To supplement overburdened pipelines, Ms. Notley brought in oil curtailment and signed a $3.7-billion contract to lease 4,400 cars to ship oil by rail.

Reality check

The election is partly a referendum on Ms. Notley’s approach to pipeline diplomacy, however, Alberta has little control over pipeline construction. Decisions on the Trans Mountain pipeline are made in Ottawa, in the courts and in consultations with First Nations. The federal government has until the end of May to respond to the latest regulatory approval of the pipeline by the National Energy Board.

Constitutional experts have warned Mr. Kenney’s plan to cut off oil to B.C. and hold a referendum on equalization could fail in the courts.

Trans Mountain at a glance

Legend

National parks

Existing pipeline

Parks

Expansion pipeline

Terminal

Indigenous lands

Pump station

Edmonton

0

80

KM

Jasper

National

Park

BRITISH

COLUMBIA

ALBERTA

Banff

National

Park

Calgary

Kamloops

Kelowna

Westridge

Van.

Sumas

Burnaby

Ferndale

WASH.

IDAHO

MONT.

Anacortes

MURAT YÜKSELIR AND JOHN SOPINSKI / THE GLOBE

AND MAIL, SOURCE: TILEZEN; OPENSTREETMAP

CONTRIBUTORS; HIU; NATURAL RESOURCES CANADA;

OPEN GOVERNMENT; GRAPHIC NEWS; KINDER MORGAN

Legend

0

80

KM

Existing pipeline

ALBERTA

Expansion pipeline

Edmonton

Indigenous lands

National parks

Parks

Jasper

National

Park

Terminal

Pump station

Banff

National

Park

Calgary

BRITISH COLUMBIA

Kamloops

Kelowna

Westridge

Vancouver

Sumas

Burnaby

WASH.

IDAHO

MONT.

Ferndale

Pacific

Ocean

Anacortes

MURAT YÜKSELIR AND JOHN SOPINSKI / THE GLOBE AND MAIL

SOURCE: TILEZEN; OPENSTREETMAP CONTRIBUTORS; HIU;

NATURAL RESOURCES CANADA; OPEN GOVERNMENT; GRAPHIC

NEWS; KINDER MORGAN

Legend

Edmonton

Existing pipeline

Expansion pipeline

16

ALBERTA

Indigenous lands

Jasper

National

Park

National parks

Parks

2

Terminal

Pump station

97

Banff

National

Park

Calgary

1

BRITISH

COLUMBIA

Kamloops

Vancouver

Island

Kelowna

Westridge

Sumas

Vancouver

Burnaby

Pacific

Ocean

Ferndale

WASH.

IDAHO

MONT.

0

80

Anacortes

KM

MURAT YÜKSELIR AND JOHN SOPINSKI / THE GLOBE AND MAIL, SOURCE: TILEZEN; OPENSTREETMAP

CONTRIBUTORS; HIU; NATURAL RESOURCES CANADA; OPEN GOVERNMENT; GRAPHIC NEWS; KINDER MORGAN

Economy and jobs

UCP

The centrepiece of Mr. Kenney’s economic plan is a proposal to cut corporate taxes from 12 to 8 per cent. Mr. Kenney has said the cut will create tens of thousands of jobs and signal businesses to invest. The UCP had initially claimed the tax cut would pay for itself through increased economic activity, however, the party’s platform says the cut will cost $2-billion over four years.

The party has said it will look to spark the economy by slashing regulations. The platform promises to reduce the youth minimum wage from $15 to $13 an hour, and will look at reducing the minimum wage for alcohol servers.

NDP

The NDP’s key economic strategy is to increase diversification in the oil patch by providing incentives to petrochemical and oil refining ventures. The party has set aside $7-billion in financing and hopes to create $75-billion in investment and tens of thousands of new jobs.

Over the past four years, the NDP government’s $3-billion diversification fund has led to the opening of a number of new refineries and petrochemical facilities near Edmonton.

The party would create a fund to help first-time home buyers and link all Albertans to high-speed internet. It has also promised to streamline regulations for small business, as well as oil and gas wells.

Reality check

Despite party promises, energy remains the main driver of the province’s economy. The biggest challenge facing Alberta will continue to be a North American market awash in oil and gas that can be produced at prices Alberta producers generally can’t match.

Story continues below advertisement

Health

UCP

The UCP has promised to maintain health spending at current levels or increase budgets, but it has not budgeted additional funds in its platform. It wants to cut administrative costs and direct savings to front-line staff. The money would also help fund an ambitious plan to reduce surgical wait times to no more than 16 weeks – hip-replacement wait times now top 37 weeks and knee replacements require 41 weeks. Private clinics will be allowed to provide major surgeries.

Two of the UCP’s largest spending promises are in health, with $40-million allocated over four years to an opioid strategy. There’s also a $100-million promise over four years to bulk up mental health and addictions services.

The party would review existing supervised drug-use sites and only fund those that have gone through rigorous consultations with local groups and an impact study. The same rules would apply to new sites.

NDP

The NDP said it would increase health budgets at the same rate as Alberta’s population. It has also committed $90-million annually to emergency rooms and would target additional funds to reduce wait times for cataract, heart and cancer surgery.

The party’s second-biggest promise is to fully cover drug prescriptions for seniors who earn less than $75,000. The program is expected to cost $110-million annually.

To combat opioids, the party has committed to opening two storefront mental-health clinics in Calgary and Edmonton. It will also sue opioid manufactures to recoup the costs of the health crisis.

Story continues below advertisement

Reality check

Alberta has one of Canada’s youngest populations and one of its most expensive health programs. The NDP reined in increasing health spending, allowing budgets to increase by only 3 per cent annually over the past four years. From 2000 to 2010, health budgets climbed by more than 9 per cent annually. Health experts have warned that the UCP’s pledge to freeze budgets isn’t realistic.

Education and child care

UCP

Mr. Kenney has promised to maintain education spending at current levels or increase it. He’s said he will cancel “discovery learning” and pause the province’s curriculum review. He’s also said he will bring back a number of standardized and assessment tests for students in Grades 1 through 3, and would lift caps on charter schools.

The UCP would rescind a law barring teachers from telling parents when students join gay-straight alliances.

NDP

The NDP said it would increase education budgets at the same rate as the province’s population. Ms. Notley has said she would build or modernize 70 schools, with funding to build new playgrounds.

The NDP’s biggest promise is to create a system of $25-a-day child care across the province over five years. With a $1.5-billion price tag, the program would expand to include 75,000 spaces and could include child care during evening and weekends to accommodate work schedules.

Reality check

Calgary has Canada’s third-most expensive child care, with a monthly space for a toddler topping $1,030. Albertans will need to decide whether or not the province can bear the additional expense. The UCP has said it won’t allocate more cash for child care while the NDP says the system would help the economy.

Story continues below advertisement

A number of protests have been held during the campaign about the UCP’s promise on the GSA issue.

Climate change

UCP

The first bill from a UCP government would repeal the carbon tax, according to Mr. Kenney. He would then file a legal challenge against the federal government’s climate plan.

The UCP’s climate strategy would impose a tax on emissions from large industrial facilities, requiring them to meet increasingly stringent targets or pay a $20 a tonne tax. The UCP would allow coal-fired power plants to remain open past 2030 and would cancel supports for renewable energy projects.

NDP

The NDP would keep the carbon tax, currently set at $30 a tonne. Future increases in the tax have been ruled out until a new pipeline is built. A proposed cap on oil sands emissions is also pending.

Ms. Notley would keep the 2030 coal phase-out date and plans to have 30 per cent of Alberta’s electricity sourced from renewables by 2030.

Reality check

The NDP’s climate plan, which includes the carbon tax and energy efficiency programs, is expected to cut 50 megatonnes of emissions by 2030. The UCP’s plan would cut 43 MT. If the federal government’s power to impose a carbon tax is upheld in court, it’s unclear what would happen to Mr. Kenney’s plan.

Story continues below advertisement

Debt and deficits

UCP

Mr. Kenney has promised to balance the province’s budget by 2022. He will do so by cutting taxes and freezing spending. By the end of a four-year mandate, government spending adjusted for inflation and population growth would be down 14 per cent for every Albertan.

With total debt approaching $100-billion, the UCP has said it would appoint an independent panel to look at Alberta’s fiscal situation, recommend how to balance the books and pay down debt.

NDP

The NDP plans for balance in 2023-24, with a boost in resource revenues paying for new social programs, including child care. A three per cent reduction in per capita spending would wipe out the deficit.

New capital projects, including a second road out of Fort McMurray, would be added to spending plans.

Reality check

Economists have expressed worry with the NDP’s projections for resource revenue growth. Both plans depend on spending restraint, which would require Alberta’s government to make difficult choices, consistently, for years.


Democracy

UCP

Mr. Kenney has promised to allow constituents to recall their MLAs. The party would require floor crossers to resign and run in a by-election before they could join the UCP. A $30,000 limit on contributions to political action committees would be set.

NDP

Ms. Notley has promised increased enforcement and stronger disclosure rules on cash funnelled to political action committees. The NDP would introduce spending limits on party leadership races.

Conflict of interest rules would be extended, barring cabinet ministers from lobbying for two years after leaving government.

Reality check

Political action committees have proliferated in Alberta’s politics prior to this election and both parties have confronted groups who can outspend them and not disclose all their funding – tough new rules should be expected.

Recall legislation in B.C. has not lead to a single politician being ousted. Alberta’s recall rules were dumped after residents attempted to recall then-premier William Aberhart.

Alberta election 2019: Required reading

Explainers

Alberta’s election is coming up on April 16. Read this first

Alberta’s recovery was on track. Then it hit a major snag

Carbon taxes in Canada: A guide to who’s affected, who pays what and who opposes them

Leader profiles

Notley has won Albertans' respect. Can she win their votes?

Kenney says Alberta is ‘under siege.’ Will voters believe him?

Riding and regional profiles

Lethbridge: A site for drug users straddles one of many political divides

Fort McMurray: Alberta’s UCP finds it’s not so simple winning the heart of the oil sands

Red Deer: Alberta’s often-overlooked third city seeks some love for local issues in election

Edmonton: City’s ex-mayor Stephen Mandel fights for middle ground in Alberta’s election



Photos: Todd Korol/The Globe and Mail; Jason Franson and Dave Chidley/The Canadian Press; Mark Blinch and Dennis Owen/Reuters; iStockphoto

Report an error Editorial code of conduct
Due to technical reasons, we have temporarily removed commenting from our articles. We hope to have this fixed soon. Thank you for your patience. If you are looking to give feedback on our new site, please send it along to feedback@globeandmail.com. If you want to write a letter to the editor, please forward to letters@globeandmail.com.

Welcome to The Globe and Mail’s comment community. This is a space where subscribers can engage with each other and Globe staff. Non-subscribers can read and sort comments but will not be able to engage with them in any way. Click here to subscribe.

If you would like to write a letter to the editor, please forward it to letters@globeandmail.com. Readers can also interact with The Globe on Facebook and Twitter .

Welcome to The Globe and Mail’s comment community. This is a space where subscribers can engage with each other and Globe staff. Non-subscribers can read and sort comments but will not be able to engage with them in any way. Click here to subscribe.

If you would like to write a letter to the editor, please forward it to letters@globeandmail.com. Readers can also interact with The Globe on Facebook and Twitter .

Discussion loading ...

Cannabis pro newsletter